facebook_pixel

NCC Says Report on U.S. Cotton Policies Misleading

The National Cotton Council (NCC) says numerous invalid assumptions severely limit the credibility of The International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development’s (ICTSD) recent paper entitled, “The 2014 Farm Bill and its Effects on the World Market.”

While the ICTSD described its paper – which includes a significant focus on crop insurance, including the Stacked Income Protection Plan (STAX) – as an “impartial, evidence-based assessment,” NCC President/CEO Dr. Gary Adams said the paper is very misleading and “does not capture the realities of today’s cotton market or global cotton policies. Cotton growers in the United States respond to market signals, not government programs, when making planting decisions.”

Adams said that the ICTSD report fails to accurately model current cotton policies, imposes crop insurance purchase decisions on the model that are not in line with historical experience, and inflates impacts by overestimating expected benefits from insurance.

The ICTSD report stands in contrast to a 2014 Congressional Research Service report that stated “… total indemnity payments under both STAX and any other cotton-specific crop insurance are prohibited from exceeding the value of the insured crop, thus further minimizing any potential production incentive.”

Another evaluation of the 2014 farm law’s cotton provisions conducted by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development concluded that “… the incentives to produce cotton in the United States will be weaker than they were during previous decades.” The report also found that “… expenditures under STAX are estimated at about one eighth of the cotton subsidies paid under the 2002 Farm Bill and about one third of the subsidies paid under the 2008 Farm Bill.”

Adams said the ICTSD paper also misrepresented the marketing loan program by failing to incorporate the modifications of the upland cotton marketing loan included in the 2014 farm law.

“Under low price scenarios, the report does not allow the marketing loan rate to adjust lower as dictated in current legislation,” Adams said.

Adams said the ICTSD report exaggerates crop insurance usage and inflates crop insurance benefits. For example, for the 2015 crop year, approximately 25% of cotton acreage is covered with a STAX policy – far below the author’s 100 percent assumption. The authors also calculate expected net indemnities of $734 million for STAX (with a $0.70 per pound futures price) – which is 2.4 times larger than the Congressional Budget Office’s estimate of $300 million.

The ICTSD report also attempts to dismiss the findings of a World Trade Organization panel that rejected Brazil’s attempt to assign production and price effects to the presence of crop insurance products. They overstate the changes in crop insurance products, Adams said, when, in reality, premium subsidy rates for individual coverage policies did not change between the 2008 and 2014 farm bills.

 

Source – National Cotton Council

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

News Stories
News

How the Ginning Cost Share Program Gained New Life

April 17, 2018

Thanks to the efforts of many in the industry, a badly-needed cotton relief program found new life on Capitol Hill.

Product News

FiberMax Honors One Ton Club Growers for 2017

April 17, 2018

The FiberMax One Ton Club recently honored 188 cotton growers who qualified for the club with their 2017 harvest results.

News

Wrangler Report Touts Value of Soil Conservation Practices

April 17, 2018

Wrangler jeans has published a report highlighting the significant economic and environmental benefits of certain cotton farming techniques.

Product News

BASF Adds Engenia Spray Tool to Aid Applications

April 16, 2018

A new easy-to-use resource puts critical weather requirements for applying Engenia herbicide in one convenient location.

Product News

Reduce Timing Guesswork for Cotton Planting

April 16, 2018

Bayer’s online Cotton Planting Forecasting tool can help growers determine the optimal planting window to improve their chances at securing a strong stand.

News

Staplcotn Acquires 50% Interest in TJ Beall Company

April 10, 2018

Staplcotn, the oldest and one of the largest cotton marketing cooperatives in the U.S., has purchased a 50% stake in the TJ Beall Company.

Product News

Deltapine NPE Program Begins Class of 19 Evaluations

April 9, 2018

Nine Class of 19 variety candidates will be in growers’ fields this year as the Deltapine New Product Evaluator (NPE) Program kicks off its eleventh season.

Around The Gin
Product News

FiberMax Honors One Ton Club Growers for 2017

April 17, 2018

The FiberMax One Ton Club recently honored 188 cotton growers who qualified for the club with their 2017 harvest results.

Product News

BASF Adds Engenia Spray Tool to Aid Applications

April 16, 2018

A new easy-to-use resource puts critical weather requirements for applying Engenia herbicide in one convenient location.

Product News

Reduce Timing Guesswork for Cotton Planting

April 16, 2018

Bayer’s online Cotton Planting Forecasting tool can help growers determine the optimal planting window to improve their chances at securing a strong stand.

Product News

Deltapine NPE Program Begins Class of 19 Evaluations

April 9, 2018

Nine Class of 19 variety candidates will be in growers’ fields this year as the Deltapine New Product Evaluator (NPE) Program kicks off its eleventh season.

Product News

Americot Expands Research and Sales Teams

April 5, 2018

Americot has added six new team members to the company’s research and sales staffs.

Product News

Greenleaf Introduces TipGuard Nozzle System

April 5, 2018

Greenleaf Technologies has introduced its new TipGuard System to protect spray tips from contact damage.

Product News

New BASF Reward Program for AR Growers Facing Dicamba Ban

March 27, 2018

BASF has revised its Grow Smart Rewards program to provide Arkansas growers alternative weed control solutions during the dicamba application ban from April 16 through October 31.

Product News

DuPont Vydate Products Fully Available for 2018

March 15, 2018

DuPont Vydate brand insecticide/nematicide products – including Vydate C-LV for cotton – will be fully available for sale and use during the 2018 growing season.

Latest News
News

How the Ginning Cost Share Program Gained New Life

April 17, 2018

Thanks to the efforts of many in the industry, a badly-needed cotton relief program found new life on Capitol Hill.

News

Wrangler Report Touts Value of Soil Conservation Practices

April 17, 2018

Wrangler jeans has published a report highlighting the significant economic and environmental benefits of certain cotton farming techniques.

News

U.S. Justice Department to Approve Bayer/Monsanto Deal

April 10, 2018

According to The Wall Street Journal, the U.S. Department of Justice has decided to approve Bayer’s acquisition of Monsanto Co., with closing expected in the second quarter of 2018.

News

Staplcotn Acquires 50% Interest in TJ Beall Company

April 10, 2018

Staplcotn, the oldest and one of the largest cotton marketing cooperatives in the U.S., has purchased a 50% stake in the TJ Beall Company.

News

NCC: Tariffs Would Harm U.S./China Cotton Trade

April 5, 2018

The National Cotton Council is concerned that proposed Chinese tariffs on U.S. raw cotton shipped to that country would harm the economic health of the U.S. cotton industry.

News

China Adds U.S. Cotton to Proposed Tariff List

April 4, 2018

U.S. cotton is now potentially impacted as the Chinese government escalated its response to United States’ tariff actions on Chinese goods.

News

Ramkumar Receives Two Prestigious Textiles Honors

March 14, 2018

Dr. Seshadri Ramkumar, a professor and researcher with Texas Tech and frequent contributor to Cotton Grower, has been awarded two of the most prestigious honors in the textiles field.

News

The Right Man for the Job

March 13, 2018

New NCC Chairman Ron Craft is more than ready for the challenges ahead for cotton.

News

NCC Praises Cochran as Champion of Agriculture

March 6, 2018

The National Cotton Council praises retiring Sen. Thad Cochran of Mississippi for his support of the U.S. cotton industry and all of agriculture during his 39-year Senate career.

News

Driving Cotton’s Unwavering Goal

March 5, 2018

With Title I coverage restored and the ginning cost share program renewed, the cotton industry remains focused on gaining additional help for growers as the new farm bill debate begins.

News

NCC Applauds Northey Confirmation to USDA Post

February 28, 2018

The National Cotton Council supports the confirmation of Bill Northey as USDA’s Under Secretary for Farm and Foreign Agricultural Service.

News

Hinnen Named Lummus Corporation CEO

February 28, 2018

Ben Hinnen has been named the new Chief Executive Officer of Lummus Corporation.

News

Cotton Achievement Award Honors Bill Lovelady

February 16, 2018

The late William T. “Bill” Lovelady, a long-time West Texas cotton producer and former NCC president, was honored as recipient of the 2017 Oscar Johnston Lifetime Achievement Award.

News

Maguire Honored with NCC Cotton Service Award

February 16, 2018

John Maguire, former NCC senior vice president for Washington Operations, is the recipient of the 2017 Harry S. Baker Distinguished Service Award.

News

Craft to Lead the National Cotton Council in 2018

February 15, 2018

Ron Craft, a cotton producer and fifth-generation ginner from Plains, TX, is the newly-elected National Cotton Council chairman for 2018.