When Glyphosate Fails – Management Strategies For Resistant Palmer Amaranth

In journalism school, professors teach aspiring writers to never use clichés, especially not two in the same sentence. But if the shoe fits, I say wear it.

Glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth grows like a weed, and according to emerging research, it could spread like wildfire too. That sentence is no good for college professors across the country, and its truth is even worse for producers throughout the Cotton Belt. Glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth ruined a few cotton fields in Georgia last year, and if not properly contained and controlled, it will become a problem elsewhere.

According to Dr. Stanley Culpepper, Extension Agronomist for Weed Science at the University of Georgia – Tifton, producers with glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth need to take precautions from preplant to layby. For those growers who haven’t dealt with the problem yet, Culpepper offers a few words of wisdom, another cliché if you will – an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. The reason is simple:

“Palmer amaranth is an extremely competitive weed, and when you think about managing it, the first thing you’ve got to think about is that Palmer is going to grow 1-3 inches a day in good growing conditions. Even in areas of Macon County where we didn’t have good growing conditions last year, it was growing an inch a day,” Culpepper said.

Unfortunately, that’s just one half of the equation. Palmer amaranth produces hundreds of thousands of seeds, and if a tolerant gene emerges, that trait can be reproduced through non-resistant plants. A field with few resistant plants one year can become choked by weeds in just a few seasons. Culpepper explains:

“One of the biggest problems we’ve got is due to the ability of this weed being able to reproduce very rapidly. If you look at average seed production per plant, when it is producing 400,000-600,000 seed per plant, this plant can quickly come in and take over a situation,” he said. “The first field we found resistance in two years ago, 25% of the population was resistant to glyphosate, which meant 75% was sensitive to glyphosate. Within two years, 75% of the population in that field is glyphosate-resistant and 25% is sensitive. That shift occurred in two years and it has got to be because of the ability of reproduction. So that’s how quickly Palmer in general can come in and take over … which in essence, in my opinion, means we go from having a chance to harvest a field to probably not being able to harvest the field at all.”

The Common Denominator

Glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth did not randomly. It developed a tolerance and adapted after application and application of glyphosate. If Culpepper could stress anything, he would harp on the fact that producers need to use herbicides that feature different modes of action. Overusing a single weed management tool, especially a broad-spectrum herbicide like glyphosate, can be devastating. At the very least, this single-pronged weed management system got many growers in the situation they are in today.

“If you look at the growers who had problems in 2005, there are several things that are very common. First of all, we were very dependent on a single management tactic. These growers had mostly Roundup Ready cotton, and they sprayed around 3-5 times a year, and that was predominantly the tool they used to manage this pest. Now they certainly were not alone in the single management tactic. Currently, there is over 100 million acres of Round-up Ready technology being grown, and in most of these cropping systems, glyphosate is the predominate weed management tool,” Culpepper said.

In addition to the heavy reliance on glyphosate as a panacea for weed management, Culpepper also said some producers use lower-than-recommended rates, a premise he understands, but the worst possible thing to do in the current situation. “Many of us are guilty of cutting herbicide rates. But I never understand why we want to cut the rate of glyphosate. It is the most effective and economical herbicide in the world, and we will cut the rate to save 25% or 50%,” he said. “I am from a family farm, so I know there are situations when it will pay to cut the rate and add an adjuvant. I am all for promoting adjuvants, but do not cut the rate. That is something that we do not need to do, especially in the situation that we are currently in.”

Is it Really That Bad?

Continuing on the path of monoculture crop systems and single-pronged weed management plans is disastrous. If the most effective and economical herbicide is deemed useless by resistance, it will be a major blow to producers everywhere. That, Culpepper said, is a reality producers need to understand.

“In this situation where we have resistance, and you take a 4X rate of Roundup, and you put it on the Palmer when it is 1 inch, the same Palmer when it is 4 inches and the same Palmer when it is 12 inches (and the palmer survives), you can clearly see we have lost the most effective and economical herbicide in the world,” Culpepper said. “And I think it is arguably the most important herbicide in the world in all production systems in agronomics today and in our state. So we have lost that in these fields, and we are going to continue to lose it as it spreads throughout our state, especially in circumstances where growers are too dependent on glyphosate.”

Grower-induced glyphosate resistance isn’t the only problem. As discussed in the weed management article in the March issue of Cotton Grower, a glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth plant can pollinate another plant from at least 200 meters away, and it is very possible that pollination can occur at even farther distances. Not only do producers have to worry about developing resistance on their farms, they also have to contend with it spreading from other areas.

“Obviously, when you have 100 million acres that you are treating with glyphosate, glyphosate, glyphosate, you will, and we did, find resistance. The problem we’ve got now is that it is going to spread, and we have to deal with it,” Culpepper said. “What we really need to do is to delay the arrival or the spread of this resistance. Once we get some number and are able to model this situation, we will be able to tell people we think it will be here in 2 years, here in 3 years, and here in 4 years. But also keep in mind that people who continue to spray glyphosate, glyphosate, glyphosate can create their own biotype in their own area, and it may be completely non-related to pollen movement.”

Recommendations

During UGA research on glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth last year, Culpepper’s team experimented with 168 different herbicide systems on 12 acres of small plot research. Of those systems, 155-160 plots had to be mowed under because of Palmer resistance, making it easy to identify possible solutions, but also emphasizing the resilience of the weed. “It makes it easy on what we are going to recommend,” Culpepper said, “because most of the things we tried simply do not work.”

For glyphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth in Roundup Ready cotton, Culpepper recommends Prowl or Treflan PPI combined with Reflex PRE during preplant or preemergence. Postemergence in 1-to 4-leaf cotton, he believes a glyphosate and Dual Magnum mix is effective if no Palmer has emerged, while a glyphosate/Staple mix should be used in Palmer that is 1-2 inches tall. For layby, MSMA combined with one of the following – Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor – is producers’ best bet. He stresses that vigilance is key to fighting gylphosate-resistant Palmer amaranth, emphasizing that managing resistant Palmer taller than 2 inches in Roundup Ready cotton is even more difficult – if not impossible.

Culpepper realizes his program will cost producers more money, especially when compared to just spraying a few applications of glyphosate. But he stresses that the program protects glyphosate, an important concept that he believes cannot be said enough, and keeps growers from an even worse scenario – mowing down there crop.

“If you look back at this program, first of all, you are going to say that I am costing you money. And I admit that. But the second thing you see is, yes, we are still using Roundup. It is still the most effective tool in 98-99% of our acreage. But what we are doing is surrounding that most important tool with three kinds of alternative herbicide chemistries with different modes of action,” Culpepper said. “This will protect the glyphosate, it will delay or help hold down ALS resistance, and it will also prevent or reduce the likelihood of resistance developing to these chemistries too, because we have three maybe four modes of action in one program. That is a sound program.”

University of Georgia Herbicide Programs for Palmer Amaranth in Cotton

Managing Glyphosate-resistant Palmer Amaranth in Roundup Ready Cotton
Preplant Incorporated (PPI)
or Preemergence (PRE)
Postemergence
(1-4 leaf cotton)
Layby Directed
Prowl or Treflan PPI + Reflex PRE Glyphosate + Dual Magnum (no Palmer emerged) or
Glyphosate + Staple
(1-2″ Palmer)
MSMA + Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor
Managing Heavy Glyphosate-sensitive Palmer Amaranth in Roundup Ready Cotton
At Plant Postemergence
(1-4 leaf cotton)
Layby Directed
Prowl/Treflan PPI or Prowl PRE
+ Cotoran, Direx, Reflex or
Staple PRE
Glyphosate +
Dual Magnum or Staple
MSMA + Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor OR Glyphosate + Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor
Managing Light to Moderate Glyphosate-sensitive Palmer Amaranth in Roundup Ready Cotton
At Plant Postemergence
(1-4 leaf cotton)
Layby Directed
Prowl/Treflan PPI or Prowl Glyphosate + Dual Magnum or Staple MSMA + Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor OR Glyphosate + Direx, Layby Pro, Suprend or Valor
PRE Prowl/Treflan PPI or Prowl PRE + Cotoran, Direx, Reflex or Staple PRE Glyphosate as needed
Topics:

Leave a Reply

Weed Control Stories
Weed Control

Thoughts on Nozzles Added to XtendiMax Label

February 22, 2017

In his fifth blog on proper stewardship of the new dicamba-based systems, Larry Steckel reviews some of the new nozzle options that have been approved for use with XtendiMax.

Weed Control

Correct Nozzle Pressures Important in Xtend System

January 31, 2017

In his fourth blog on proper stewardship of the new dicamba products on Xtend crops, Larry Steckel takes a second look at the pressure ranges for optimum nozzle use.

Weed Control

Watch the Wind in Xtend Crop System

January 23, 2017

In his third blog on stewardship of the Xtend Crop System, Larry Steckel turns his attention to the wind – more specifically, wind speed and direction.

Young Cotton Plant
Weed Control

Use the Correct Nozzles in the Xtend Crop System

January 17, 2017

Larry Steckel turns his focus to nozzles in his second blog on stewardship of XtendiMax and Engenia on Xtend crops.

Weed Control

Proper Use of Correct Herbicides in Xtend Crop System

January 16, 2017

Tennessee Extension Weed Specialist Larry Steckel is working to help growers prepare to properly use and manage newly-approved dicamba and 2,4-D herbicide options.

Weed Control

The Auxin Wait is Over

January 11, 2017

The auxin herbicide era of cotton weed control has begun. It’s time for growers to get up to speed on the federal and state do’s and don’ts for properly using the products.

Weed Control

Farmers Moving to Dominant Traits

November 16, 2016

In 2016, cotton growers demonstrated their preference for innovative weed-driven trait solutions.

Around The Gin
Product News

Six Greenleaf Nozzles Approved for Use with XtendiMax

February 24, 2017

Six TurboDrop D Series nozzles from Greenleaf Technologies have been approved for use with Monsanto’s XtendiMax herbicide with VaporGrip Technology.

Product News

EPA Approves DuPont’s FeXapan Dicamba Herbicide

February 17, 2017

DuPont has received EPA registration for FeXapan herbicide plus VaporGrip Technology, a low-volatility dicamba formulation for use on cotton and soybean varieties carrying traits that provide tolerance to dicamba and glyphosate herbicides.

Product News

Fourteen Southern States Register Enlist Duo for Use on Enlist Crops

February 14, 2017

Thirteen Southern states have granted state registration of Enlist Duo herbicide for use on Enlist cotton and other crops, following federal registration received in January.

Product News

BASF Application Academy Adds Online Training Module

February 2, 2017

BASF has added an online training module to its On Target Application Academy stewardship program to help increase education of new and advanced herbicide technologies.

Product News

Bayer Offers Shared Risk Program for FiberMax, Stoneville Growers

January 26, 2017

Bayer is helping support the economic sustainability of cotton growers through the company’s 2017 Shared Risk Program for those who plant FiberMax and Stoneville cotton seed.

Product News

Enlist Duo Herbicide Registered for Use on Enlist Cotton

January 13, 2017

The U.S. EPA has registered Enlist Duo herbicide for use on Enlist cotton varieties, beginning in 2017.

Product News

Data Show Yield Gains from Indigo Cotton in 2016

January 9, 2017

Data collected from 2016 trials show that Indigo Cotton – a seed treatment based on naturally occurring, in-plant microbes to help increase water use efficiency – led to yield improvements on testing acres, including an 11% average yield increase in West Texas.

Product News

FiberMax and Stoneville Release New Varieties for 2017

January 9, 2017

Cotton growers searching to match the right variety the right field now have two new FiberMax varieties and two new Stoneville varieties to consider for 2017.

Latest News
Weed Control

Thoughts on Nozzles Added to XtendiMax Label

February 22, 2017

In his fifth blog on proper stewardship of the new dicamba-based systems, Larry Steckel reviews some of the new nozzle options that have been approved for use with XtendiMax.

Weed Control

Texas Outlines Best Management Practices for New Auxin Herbicides

January 31, 2017

The approval and availability of three new herbicides for use with auxin-tolerant cotton varieties in 2017 means that growers will need a keen understanding of the products and their proper use.

Weed Control

Correct Nozzle Pressures Important in Xtend System

January 31, 2017

In his fourth blog on proper stewardship of the new dicamba products on Xtend crops, Larry Steckel takes a second look at the pressure ranges for optimum nozzle use.

Weed Control

Watch the Wind in Xtend Crop System

January 23, 2017

In his third blog on stewardship of the Xtend Crop System, Larry Steckel turns his attention to the wind – more specifically, wind speed and direction.

Weed Control

Use the Correct Nozzles in the Xtend Crop System

January 17, 2017

Larry Steckel turns his focus to nozzles in his second blog on stewardship of XtendiMax and Engenia on Xtend crops.

Weed Control

Flag the Technology Program Expands in Texas

January 16, 2017

The Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service and the Texas Plant Protection Association have collaborated on a Flag the Technology program that identifies crop fields sensitive to certain herbicides.

Weed Control

Proper Use of Correct Herbicides in Xtend Crop System

January 16, 2017

Tennessee Extension Weed Specialist Larry Steckel is working to help growers prepare to properly use and manage newly-approved dicamba and 2,4-D herbicide options.

Weed Control

The Auxin Wait is Over

January 11, 2017

The auxin herbicide era of cotton weed control has begun. It’s time for growers to get up to speed on the federal and state do’s and don’ts for properly using the products.

Weed Control

Farmers Moving to Dominant Traits

November 16, 2016

In 2016, cotton growers demonstrated their preference for innovative weed-driven trait solutions.

Cotton Production

EPA Registers Dicamba Formulation for Use On Dicamba Tolerant Crops

November 9, 2016

The EPA has registered Monsanto's XtendiMax with Vapor Grip technology - a new, low volatility dicamba formulation - for use in weed control programs in cotton and soybean crops engineered for dicamba tolerance.

Weed Control

Managing Glyphosate-Resistant Italian Ryegrass

October 14, 2016

Problems with glyphosate-resistant Italian ryegrass escalated during 2016 in Mississippi. Extension Specialist Jason Bond offers several post-harvest management suggestions.

Weed Control

Post-Direct and Hooded Options for Pigweed Control

July 7, 2016

Considering how Palmer amaranth – or pigweed – seems to just keep coming this year, directed layby applications are critical for maintaining consistent pigweed control.

Weed Control

Cut Down on Weed Escapes

June 28, 2016

As new types of resistance appear, keep a sharp eye out for pigweed escapes.

Weed Control

New Webcast Outlines Flag the Technology Program

June 22, 2016

A new webcast explaining the use and value of the University of Arkansas’ Flag the Technology program has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

Weed Control

Preserving Weed Management Tools through Good Stewardship

May 9, 2016

Cotton growers looking for ways to cut trips across their fields to save money and time could be doing more harm than good – especially when it comes to weed management.