Shurley: So Much for 18 Million Bales and Higher Prices

Shurley: So Much for 18 Million Bales and Higher Prices

Prior to the August 10 USDA crop production estimates, the 2017 U.S. cotton crop was projected at 19 million bales. There seemed to be general consensus, given the crop conditions in parts of Texas, that the crop would not get bigger with this month’s report. There was some belief that the crop is actually less than 19 million (more in the 18 million neighborhood), but that this may not be reflected yet in the August numbers.

The revised crop estimate for August is now 20.55 million bales – 1.55 million bales more than the July estimate. Not only did the crop not hold at around 19 million bales, but now, if we’re indeed going to eventually retreat to the 18 million bale mark, we’ve got another million and a half bales to cull through.


But, you know what, maybe not all is lost. Apparently, quite a few farmers are looking at a potentially good crop and, with any luck or good decisions on marketing and risk management, stand to possibly do relatively well.

The market certainly didn’t like these new numbers. December futures had improved and were trending up since mid-July – breaking back above 70 cents on August 2. Prices danced around the 71-cent mark until the August report, dropping about 2 cents on the report and limit down 3 cents for the day.

While the revised crop estimate was a shock compared to the July projections, U.S. 2017 crop year Ending Stocks are only ½ million bales higher than the July projection. This is because also in this month’s report:

  • Exports for the just completed 2016 crop year were adjusted up 420,000 bales, reducing carry-in stocks to the 2017 crop year.
  • Projected exports for the 2017 crop year were increased 700,000 bales, likely reflecting higher available export supply.

The crop is now estimated at 20.55 million bales on an average yield of 892 pounds per acre. If realized, this would equal the record U.S. average yield achieved in 2012. Eight states are currently projected to have an average yield above last year. Twelve states are expected to have a yield above their 5-year average.

The August numbers are the first based on a farmer survey for 2017. Data collection (farmer responses) occurred from July 29 to August 3. Also (for cotton only), actual plant counts and measurements were taken July 25 to August 1.

Crop conditions in Texas have declined over the growing season. Texas yield is projected at 742 pounds per acre compared to 749 last year – essentially the same. As of August 6 (after the yield survey data collection and plant measurements), the Texas crop condition was 3.30 compared to 3.19 last year at the same time. The entire U.S. crop is rated at 3.53, compared to 3.37 last year. Georgia – the second largest in cotton acreage – is expected to yield 1,039 pounds per acre compared to 898 last year and 5-year average of 936. If realized, this would be 52 pounds below the record in 2012.

There is opinion that the USDA August estimate of 20.55 million bales will be reduced in future reports. I’m not going to second-guess USDA. The number is what it is. And regardless of what one thinks about the number, the market will deal with it until something else comes along.

Elsewhere in the report, on the foreign and World scene:

  • The China crop projection was increased ½ million bales and mill use increased by ½ million bales. Stocks were unchanged.
  • World use/demand for the 2017 crop year was increased a net 370,000 bales, due largely to the increase in China.
  • China imports remain at 5 million bales. Imports were revised up for Mexico, Turkey, Indonesia, Bangladesh, and Vietnam – all major markets for U.S. exports.
  • The projected India and Australia crops were unchanged from the July estimates.

After the report-induced decline, prices (December futures) now hover at the 68 cent level, washing out most of the gain since mid-July. Prices could improve if crop conditions and yield outlook worsens. But, like I said earlier, the market now has a 1½ million bale cushion it didn’t have before.

Some observers are convinced the U.S. crop will only get smaller. All we really know is that the market has to digest and make what it will of the 20.55 number for now. If the September numbers continue to validate a 20+ million bale crop, then prices could decline further. If the crop does get smaller, the 68 to 70 cent level or better should hold.