Cotton Vs. Corn: Paradox Proves Logic

Thesis, antithesis, synthesis: The Hegelian dialectic triad.

Wilhelm F. Hegel was an 18th-century German philosopher who believed that all things logical begin with a thought (thesis), which is then challenged by an opposite thought (antithesis). The two antagonists feed off of each other to create a positive (synthesis). Through synthesis, both the thesis and antithesis are proven to be correct. Paradox proves logic, Hegel believed.

The process is progressive, with synthesis then becoming theory. And on and on — ad infinitum — the philosophy tells us.

Hegel’s association of ideas became known as “dialectical thinking,” and there are hundreds, maybe thousands, of explanations for what it is. The fact that makes dialectical thinking almost impossible to define is that it can only be seen in practice.

Can Hegel’s triad be applied to today’s cotton and grains markets? Absolutely. Can the triad’s synthesis be proven? Not yet. But two sides of the triangle — thesis and antithesis — are definitely in place.

For the Cotton Belt, the thesis is that what is good for grains — particularly corn — is bad for cotton. The antithesis, of course, is that it is not. The synthesis is that growers who switch to grains and increase acreage will make money through the incredible rise in prices. At the same time, cotton acreage will decline, world stocks follow suit and cotton prices rise.

Exclusive of Hegel’s rationale, the years in which cotton acreage is declining will be painful. But to put it into a sports metaphor: No pain, no gain.

The Triad In Practice?

If there is to be synthesis, it is to believe what two heavyweights in the cotton industry have to say.

• Billy Dunavant, chairman of the board and CEO of Memphis-based Dunavant Enterprises, the world’s largest privately owned cotton merchandising company, in an exclusive interview with Cotton Grower editors:

“As I look ahead, the best thing going for cotton is the price of competing agricultural products — corn, soybeans and wheat. Competing crops are home runs right now. (Growers) can make good money on corn at $3.50, and soybeans at $7. It will reduce cotton acres, but it gives cotton a chance to reduce its carryover, and maybe have prices right themselves. It’s going to take cotton acres (out of production); in the Mid-South in particular. Good can come out of it.

“I think you will see American cotton — maybe 18 months from now — be competitive again. Supply and demand numbers look more favorable 12 months out.”

• Anthony Tancredi, vice president, Allenberg Cotton Co., also based in Memphis, at a Monsanto/Stoneville Pedigreed Seed Co. meeting in late December:

“Grains are trying their best to squeeze out cotton acreage, and so far it is working.

“Nothing changes a bad situation like a bad situation. … If people look at how bad things are, and the market does its job, it should get some land out of cotton because we have proven that we do not need it. But there is enough underlying strength in the cotton market that it cannot be dismal forever.”

The Domino Theory

The explosion in the grain markets had to start somewhere, and the planets were perfectly aligned.

The dominoes began to fall in Australia, which is in what some have termed a 1,000-year drought. Australia is the world’s third largest wheat exporter. According to reports, Australia exported 25.1 million tons (metric) of wheat in 2005. In 2006, it is projected that the country will produce only 10 million tons. If the situation Down Under plays out as predicted, Australia will be a net importer of wheat, rather than a net exporter.

“Prices have taken off,” says Tancredi. “A lot of people were caught short and wheat prices exploded. All of a sudden people’s attention turned to grains.”

And attention turned to corn especially. During the time the Australian wheat crop was burning up, fuel prices reached record levels, with the price of regular gas exceeding $3 per gallon in many areas. That helped to create an almost unbelievable increase in domestic demand for ethanol and biodiesel. Bloomberg News says corn futures actually rose 31% during the 2006 harvest, a time when prices fundamentally retreat. This despite the third largest corn crop the U.S. has ever produced. The record crop in 2004 dropped corn prices from $3.40 per bushel in the spring of the year to $1.94 during harvest. For 2006, corn prices are up around 70% over 2005.

The Potash Institute reports that over the past four years, production of ethanol has doubled to more than 12 billion gallons per year. Production of biodiesel has risen to 1 billion gallons per year.

Then there are soybeans. The fundamentals for soybeans are not as bullish as those for corn, but in the Midwest, for just about every corn acre that is added, an acre of soybeans is subtracted. Soybean acreage will rise in the Mid-South at the expense of cotton and rice.

“Beans have made a decent recovery,” says Tancredi, “but everybody is talking about beans as a follower, not a leader.”

Facing Cotton’s Problems

“We were faced with droughts in Texas, Georgia and Alabama. Mississippi had some rain issues (in 2006),” Tancredi says. “In the face of all this, the U.S. harvested way more than was expected. We averaged 798 pounds-per-acre, the third highest yield in history. I’m not sure anybody in the marketplace expected 21.3 million bales.”

But that is what we got. Add that production to 6 million bales of carryover, and based on current demand, the world has too much cotton. And a figure of 6 million bales in stocks may be too low, Dunavant believes: “I will tell you … it’s going to be 7.5 million bales.” Tancredi put his carryover number at 6.5 million.

Back to the Australian drought, Dunavant Enterprises owns three gins that normally turn out over 300,000 bales per year. “We’ll be lucky to gin 80,000 bales,” Dunavant says. But with global production being what it is, the market has not reacted in the least to Australian difficulties.

Another problem is that USDA has the U.S. scheduled to export 16.2 million bales this marketing year, but Dunavant believes it’ll be closer to 13.5 million.

Leave a Reply

Marketing Stories
Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: June Numbers Leave Bulls in the Corral for Now

June 12, 2015

Cotton growers are optimistically waiting for prices to break to the upside. But patience is wearing thin.

Market Analysis

Shurley On Cotton: A New Floor for Planted Acres

July 2, 2015

  By Dr. Don Shurley The long-awaited and much anticipated first estimates of actual crop acres planted for 2015 are

Market Analysis

Will Spring Rains Offer Price Relief in 2015?

July 2, 2015

Will this year’s decline in planted acres offer some price release sometime soon? That’s the question waiting for an answer.

OA Cleveland
Market Analysis

Late Week Fireworks Could Signal Something Bullish for Cotton

June 29, 2015

Round and round and round she goes… Where she stop no one knows. The circus crier could have found employment

Market Analysis

Unchanged Variables Keep Market Moving Nowhere Fast

June 22, 2015

It’s the lull before the storm, and nothing in the cotton market will change until Mother Nature makes her decisions.

Market Analysis

Marking Time Thanks to USDA, China and Mother Nature

June 14, 2015

The cotton market marked time this past week, thanks to USDA, China and Mother Nature.

OA Cleveland
Market Analysis

Cotton Market Poised to Respond to Mother Nature

June 8, 2015

The range bound trading continues for cotton without any change in sight until time passes and Mother Nature does what

Around The Gin
Product News

Ratting Out Copper Theft

June 10, 2015

A simple alarm technology is helping to stop copper thieves who target irrigation systems.

Product News

EPA Approves New Premix for 2016 for Cotton, Soybean Weed Control

May 29, 2015

Cotton and soybean growers will have a new weed control option in 2016 with Warrant Ultra Herbicide, a premix of acetochlor and fomesafen.

Product News

Deltapine NPE Program Begins Eighth Year of On-Farm Variety Evaluation

April 28, 2015

Nearly 200 farmers will be part of the Deltapine New Product Evaluator program this year to help evaluate cotton variety candidates for the Deltapine Class of 16.

Product News

EPA Approves Enlist Duo Herbicide for Use in Additional States

April 2, 2015

The EPA has approved Enlist Duo herbicide for use in nine additional states, including four in the Cotton Belt.

Product News

New 2015 CROPLAN Cotton Varieties Feature Bollgard II XtendFlex Technology

March 19, 2015

WinField is adding Monsanto’s new Bollgard II XtendFlex cotton trait to two new CROPLAN cotton varieties for 2015.

Precision Technology

New Features for TeeJet Aeros 9040 Field Computer

March 18, 2015

TeeJet has added new features to its Aeros 9040 Field Computer for 2015.

Precision Technology

TeeJet Launches New DynaJet Flex Nozzle Control System

March 17, 2015

The new DynaJet Flex 7120 nozzle control system from TeeJet Technologies helps growers manage spray quality across a variety of operating speeds and application rates.

Product News

New Cheminova Chemistry to Help Control Herbicide Resistant Weeds

February 23, 2015

Cheminova plans to register pethoxamid, a new herbicide active ingredient, to help growers manage herbicide-resistant weeds.

Latest News
Market Analysis

Shurley On Cotton: A New Floor for Planted Acres

July 2, 2015

  By Dr. Don Shurley The long-awaited and much anticipated first estimates of actual crop acres planted for 2015 are

Market Analysis

Will Spring Rains Offer Price Relief in 2015?

July 2, 2015

Will this year’s decline in planted acres offer some price release sometime soon? That’s the question waiting for an answer.

Market Analysis

Late Week Fireworks Could Signal Something Bullish for Cotton

June 29, 2015

Round and round and round she goes… Where she stop no one knows. The circus crier could have found employment

Market Analysis

Unchanged Variables Keep Market Moving Nowhere Fast

June 22, 2015

It’s the lull before the storm, and nothing in the cotton market will change until Mother Nature makes her decisions.

Market Analysis

Marking Time Thanks to USDA, China and Mother Nature

June 14, 2015

The cotton market marked time this past week, thanks to USDA, China and Mother Nature.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: June Numbers Leave Bulls in the Corral for Now

June 12, 2015

Cotton growers are optimistically waiting for prices to break to the upside. But patience is wearing thin.

Market Analysis

Cotton Market Poised to Respond to Mother Nature

June 8, 2015

The range bound trading continues for cotton without any change in sight until time passes and Mother Nature does what

Market Analysis

Mother Nature Now Controls the Market

June 1, 2015

Mother Nature has taken control of the market, thanks to weather-related acreage losses in the U.S., India and China.

Promotion

Blue Jeans Go Green Supports Habitat for Humanity Build-A-Thon

May 28, 2015

Cotton Incorporated’s Blue Jeans Go Green program turned 10,000 pairs of used blue jeans into UltraTouch Denim insulation for use in a Habitat For Humanity Build-A-Thon in New Orleans.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: Prices Steady, But Tempting Downside Support

May 27, 2015

Amid the volatility and unknowns of the cotton market, this much we know – cotton production in 2015 will require patience, a clear understanding of the risks and careful evaluation of marketing tools and choices.

Market Analysis

Weather Worries Put Cotton Market on the Defensive

May 26, 2015

The cotton market found itself on the defensive this past week, as weather issues in all cotton-producing countries helped drive the dollar higher and prices lower.

Market Analysis

Plexus: Look for Tight, Long-Term Trading Range

May 22, 2015

The market has encountered both strong support and resistance to keep prices confined to narrow trading ranges for both July and December cotton.

Market Analysis

Despite Bearish Reports, Cotton Continues to Hold the Higher Ground

May 16, 2015

The cotton market continues to defy the onslaught of bearish shots across its bow.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: No Surprises in May USDA Numbers, Sideways Market Continues

May 13, 2015

USDA’s May WASDE report contains the first U.S. and World estimates for the 2015 crop year, and the numbers are about as expected – some better than expected.

Promotion

Organizers Gearing Up for Celebrate Cotton Game at Texas Tech

May 12, 2015

It’s not uncommon for universities to recognize the importance of agriculture. It is uncommon, however, for one to go to great lengths to highlight the importance of a single crop.