facebook_pixel

Don’t Be Your Own Worst Enemy

From Cotton Grower Magazine – August/September 2016

Beck Barnes

I went home this summer to attend a Dow AgroSciences field day in the Mississippi Delta.

After the event, I stopped in at my favorite lunch spot and got to hang out with some old friends over a sandwich and a cold Coke. Someone asked where I had been that day, and I mentioned that I had been at a Dow event learning up on the new Enlist technology.

“Oh, I think I had some of that Enlist technology show up over at my place this week,” said one farmer at the table. “It was either that or the dicamba one.”

I knew exactly what he meant. It wasn’t the first time this season that I’d heard a cotton producer grumble about a neighbor going off label and spraying a herbicide product that is currently not registered for use in cotton.

The problem, of course, is that growers who are willing to make an illegal application almost assuredly aren’t following label instructions with respect to things like wind speed, boom height and applicator speed. To compound matters, many are using older formulations of herbicide – formulations that don’t feature the new age chemistry created by Monsanto and Dow that helps keep their respective herbicides on target.

Without fail, the victims in these situations don’t want to make a fuss about it. No reason to spoil a friendly relationship over an accident, they seem to think. But since my neighbors here in Midtown Memphis haven’t planted any crops this year, allow me to get this off my chest: making illegal sprays of dicamba and 2,4-D in 2016 is profoundly selfish and dumb.

The risk-to-reward ratio here just doesn’t justify this activity. At best, a grower making these applications gets moderately better weed control in one crop. At worst, he spurs the call to EPA that breaks the camel’s back, effectively robbing thousands of his fellow farmers of access to a game-changing, fortune-saving technology.

Make no mistake, the state and federal agencies who field these complaints have noticed the uptick in activity this year. Particularly in the Mid-South, with its traditionally diverse cropping landscape, state pesticide control departments have been flooded with calls.

It’s a shame, truly. So many farmers, researchers, consultants and agronomists have waited anxiously for years, anticipating these new tools in the fight against weed resistance. The introduction of dicamba- and 2,4-D-tolerant traits would mean less resistance pressure on existing glyphosate and glufosinate technologies. Literally everyone stands to benefit from the new technologies gaining federal approval. Now, in a vulnerable moment in the registration process, a few irresponsible farmers are threatening to jeopardize it all.

Here’s hoping USDA understands what is plain to see – that the illegal applications that have happened this season are vastly different from the safe, meticulously researched and vigorously tested systems designed by Monsanto and Dow. If not, well, we’ll have only ourselves to blame.

Editor’s Note: Two separate Mid-South state plant boards have confirmed to Cotton Grower that they have received no complaints regarding off-target drift of 2,4-D herbicides to date in 2016. Further, representatives of Dow AgroSciences say they have not received any complaints regarding off-label use of 2,4-D on Enlist crops in 2016. Cotton Grower’s editorial position on this issue remains unchanged: off-label sprays of any herbicide in 2016 are entirely irresponsible and damaging to the American cotton industry as a whole.

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

Opinion Stories
Opinion

Cotton’s New Year’s Resolutions

January 10, 2018

What would a list of New Year’s Resolutions look like for the U.S. cotton industry? Beck Barnes has some thoughts to consider.

Opinion

Several Factors Vital to U.S. Cotton Industry Growth

October 31, 2017

Maintaining market share, enhanced consumer awareness and continued investments in research and development are needed to keep the U.S. cotton industry advancing.

Opinion

Five-Year-Old Girl Enthused by Cotton Research

October 27, 2017

A visit to a cotton research lab can help encourage students – even five-year-old girls – to consider a career in science.

Opinion

Creating Novel Functional Cottons

September 15, 2017

Incorporation of biological molecules to cotton may lead to development of novel functional cottons.

Opinion

Outlook Still Optimistic for Texas Cotton

September 2, 2017

Hurricane Harvey has focused the eyes of the world on Texas. Although cotton losses along the Gulf Coast are substantial, there is still optimism for a bumper crop as the High Plains moves toward harvest.

Opinion

No One Reason for “Frustrating” Dicamba Issue

July 18, 2017

Tennessee Weed Specialist Larry Steckel has walked hundreds of drift-damaged soybean fields in the past few weeks. He shares some opinions about possible reasons for the problem.

Opinion

Global Cotton Must Confront Polyester

February 23, 2017

In the face of massive shifts in consumption, member nations of the WTO must hold polyester to the same standards as cotton.

Around The Gin
Product News

Bayer Shares the Risk with Cotton Farmers

January 26, 2018

Bayer offers replant, crop loss and yield protection to growers who plant FiberMax and Stoneville cotton seed.

Product News

Americot Adds New Sales Support in GA, KS and TX

January 23, 2018

Americot has expanded its sales support team in Georgia, Kansas and the Rolling Plains of Texas.

Product News

Indigo Offers Premium for Indigo Cotton Production

January 9, 2018

Indigo Ag has announced a new program that offers significant price premiums for U.S. cotton growers who contract to grow Indigo Cotton.

Product News

New Bayer Varieties Focus on High Yield, Adaptability

January 5, 2018

Bayer releases five new FiberMax and Stoneville varieties for introduction in 2018.

Product News

New PhytoGen TRiO Guards Cottonseed Investment

January 3, 2018

New PhytoGen TRiO seed treatment helps provide early season protection for young cottonseed from diseases, insects and nematodes.

Product News

Americot Adds Seven to Sales, Research Teams

December 20, 2017

Americot has added seven new sales and research associates to the company’s staff across the Cotton Belt.

Product News

Seven New Varieties in Deltapine Class of 18

December 11, 2017

Seven new varieties – including five Bollgard 3 XtendFlex offerings – join the Deltapine product lineup as the Class of 18.

Product News

Special Roundup Ready PLUS Incentives for Arkansas

December 7, 2017

Monsanto is offering a special Roundup Ready PLUS Crop Management Solutions platform in Arkansas for 2018 for growers planting XtendFlex cotton and Roundup Ready 2 Xtend soybean varieties.

Latest News
Opinion

Cotton’s New Year’s Resolutions

January 10, 2018

What would a list of New Year’s Resolutions look like for the U.S. cotton industry? Beck Barnes has some thoughts to consider.

Opinion

Plow Thru Cancer With Me, Won’t You?

November 10, 2017

Cotton Grower Editor/Publisher Beck Barnes gets personal about family and St. Jude...and shares a special request for the cotton community.

Opinion

Several Factors Vital to U.S. Cotton Industry Growth

October 31, 2017

Maintaining market share, enhanced consumer awareness and continued investments in research and development are needed to keep the U.S. cotton industry advancing.

Opinion

Five-Year-Old Girl Enthused by Cotton Research

October 27, 2017

A visit to a cotton research lab can help encourage students – even five-year-old girls – to consider a career in science.

Opinion

Creating Novel Functional Cottons

September 15, 2017

Incorporation of biological molecules to cotton may lead to development of novel functional cottons.

Opinion

Outlook Still Optimistic for Texas Cotton

September 2, 2017

Hurricane Harvey has focused the eyes of the world on Texas. Although cotton losses along the Gulf Coast are substantial, there is still optimism for a bumper crop as the High Plains moves toward harvest.

International

Some New Thoughts for the Cotton Industry

August 23, 2017

Dr. Seshadri Ramkumar of Texas Tech spent part of his summer in India, observing and discussing the country’s cotton industry and goals. He shares some of his observations in this commentary.

Opinion

No One Reason for “Frustrating” Dicamba Issue

July 18, 2017

Tennessee Weed Specialist Larry Steckel has walked hundreds of drift-damaged soybean fields in the past few weeks. He shares some opinions about possible reasons for the problem.

Opinion

Global Cotton Must Confront Polyester

February 23, 2017

In the face of massive shifts in consumption, member nations of the WTO must hold polyester to the same standards as cotton.

Opinion

Cotton Industry Begins Year with Optimism

January 20, 2017

Higher global cotton production and increased demand is the current state of the cotton industry.

Opinion

Is Our 2017 Acreage Estimate Too Low?

January 10, 2017

If our estimate holds true, or if it proves lower than what actually transpires next season, it could mean great things for American cotton in 2017 and beyond.

Opinion

Don’t Be Your Own Worst Enemy

September 7, 2016

At a key moment in the registration process for new weed control technologies, a few irresponsible farmers are threatening to jeopardize it all.

Opinion

Cotton Incorporated Strikes Back

June 28, 2016

When bullies come after our industry, who is better equipped to stare them down than Cotton Incorporated?

Opinion

For Vilsack, the Time is Now

March 1, 2016

It’s time for Tom Vilsack to provide some value to America’s beleaguered cotton industry.

Opinion

Finding the Next Generation of Cotton Farmers

December 8, 2015

The cotton industry needs an influx of young energy that have an eye on the health of American cotton as a whole. The good news is that young people open to a career in agriculture exist.