The Enigmatic Whitefly

By |

In the grand scheme of things, silverleaf whiteflies are way down on the list of economically damaging pests Beltwide.

In 2007, for instance, whiteflies ranked well below the bollworm/budworm complex, lygus, thrips and fleahoppers in economic losses. According to Beltwide data from the Cotton Foundation and Mississippi State University, bollworms/budworms destroyed 229,186 bales; whiteflies 14,817.

But looking at it from another angle, growers spent an average of $2.73 per acre for bollworm/budworm control, while one application of a whitefly material could run nearly $27 per acre, making it far and away the most expensive per-acre treatment. Comparing Beltwide averages versus a single treatment is not apples-to-apples, but it does underscore what a costly problem whiteflies can be.

Whiteflies cause yield loss and premature defoliation, and the honeydew they secrete can lead to discounted fiber quality through sticky cotton. But they are somewhat of an enigma in the Southeast: they are not an annual pest in most cases, and they usually confine themselves to late-planted, hairy-leaf varieties during periods of extended drought.

Getting The Knack Of It

Insect growth regulators are effective tools for whitefly control, and one of those is Knack from Valent.
“Knack affects several stages of the whitefly life cycle, but it does not kill adults directly,” says Valent’s Jeff Smith. “When adult females come into contact with Knack, they will lay sterile eggs; they won’t hatch. If it contacts viable eggs, it will prevent them from hatching and it also prevents late-stage nymphs from turning into adults.”
Whiteflies require as little as 18 days to develop from egg to adult under warm temperatures, according to University of Georgia data.
“Allowing whiteflies to reproduce at a high rate in the field can lead to significant yield loss, mostly due to nymphs,” Smith continues. “But what Knack does is break the life cycle; meaning nymphs will begin to cycle out and they won’t come back.”
Another important factor in the effectiveness of Knack is that it is a translaminar. Whiteflies develop on the bottom of the cotton leaf, and translaminar products are absorbed on the upper leaf surface and move through the leaf to the target area.
“The real key for Knack is timing,” says Smith. “You cannot wait for the whitefly population to get out of hand to get the most benefit. Growers need to apply Knack early before a population explodes. If you break the life cycle early, whiteflies will not impact yield.”
Smith recommends growers attack whiteflies earlier in the year with split applications of Knack: “We want growers to be more proactive. Georgia cotton tends to be vegetative for a longer period of time, and we want to protect new growth. We recommend 5 ounces of Knack when adults average three to five per leaf plus one nymph, then a re-treatment of 5 ounces 14 days later if needed.”

“Historically, silverleaf whiteflies are a pest in more arid environments, such as Arizona,” says Georgia Extension entomologist Dr. Phillip Roberts. “And you can occasionally find banded-winged whiteflies in other areas across the Belt.”

But in 2007, the silverleaf whitefly was most definitely a problem in pockets of south Georgia, especially in the late-planted, hairy-leaf varieties. Data from the University of California Extension service suggests that moisture builds up on the bottom of foliage in hairy-leaf varieties, and those varieties tend to hold that moisture for longer periods of time compared to smooth-leaf cottons. That makes hairy-leaf varieties much more attractive to thirsty whiteflies than smooth-leaf.

“What we had in places in Georgia in 2007 were the factors that make whiteflies an economic problem – droughty conditions and late planted, hairy-leaf varieties in spots where we hurt beneficial insects,” Roberts says.

Jeff Smith, a field market development specialist with Valent adds, “Last year was a perfect storm for whiteflies in Georgia – hot and dry.” Valent markets the insect growth regulator Knack, which is labeled for use in cotton on whiteflies.

“If whiteflies infest cotton before cutout – mid-August through mid-September, depending on planting date – that should influence how you manage other pests,” Roberts continues. “For example, if you see whiteflies in early August, you need to conserve beneficials if you can. But if you have to spray for something like stinkbugs, then you need to use a product that will also give whitefly suppression.”

According to Roberts, University of Georgia test plots planted the first of May last year had virtually no problems with whiteflies; those planted the first of June did.


Dr. Phillip Roberts

Sidebar caption photo:

Silverleaf whitefly


Whiteflies lay eggs and develop on the bottoms of leaves.

Gantz is the editor of Cotton Grower magazine. Over the years, he has won many National Agricultural Marketing Association awards, including two national NAMAs – one in advertising and one in public relations. Gantz brings hands-on experience, having worked as Sales Manager for an agricultural supply distributor in the Mississippi Delta.

Leave a Reply