Corn Crashes Cotton’s Party?

Cotton growers have had a peaceful coexistence with what Native Americans called “maize” for a couple of decades. Maybe longer. A cotton/corn rotation is a case of mutualism: both crops benefit. Corn builds organic matter and is not the best host for the nematodes that cruise the Cotton Belt; cotton herbicides take down weeds that corn herbicides can’t.

The most common rotation has been 2-3 years in cotton, 1 year in corn. And that 1 year in — at least 1 year in — for potentially thousands of growers, will be 2007. The basic functions of supply and demand have driven corn futures to 10-year highs. Despite a bumper crop in 2006 — the third largest in history — the stocks-to-use ratio is the lowest since people started tracking such things. In other words, corn is short. And at the same time, cotton is not.

But what has driven this historic demand for corn? A couple of things:

• The world’s consumers, economists say, have the pocket money to buy more grains as protein sources. And as for competing sources of protein, there’s that pesky health thing with red meat and some fish. Right now hamburger lovers are being bombarded with health warnings that would make C. Everett Koop proud. (You remember Koop, right? Looked like a heavy-weight Abraham Lincoln. Hated cigarettes.) And ocean fish has a lot of mercury in it, some say. Besides, if you believe what noted eco-specialist Ted Danson said 15 years ago, the oceans died 5 years ago. So nothing is biting anyway.

• “Bio”fuel demand has skyrocketed. Over the past 4 years, according to the PotashCorp – a world leader in nitrogen, phosphate and potash production – production of ethanol has doubled to more than 12 billion gallons per year. About one billion gallons of biodiesel — “the second most popular alternative fuel made from plant sources,” the company says — were produced.

On the Chicago Board of Trade, corn futures are trending in the $3.50-$4.00 range, and some analysts say it will take $5 per bushel to slow down demand. Even at the current price, that’s a jump of 77% in the past year.

A Wall Street source told Bloomberg News that for every 10-cent rise in corn prices, a nickel is taken off the share-price of Tyson Foods’ stock, due to increased feed costs. Bloomberg says even Coca-Cola, which uses corn syrup as a sweetener, is feeling it. Cattle and hog producers are too. Obviously the price of corn flakes is going up; less obviously, so is the price of ice cream. (I wonder if the price of corn hooch has gone up?)

So growers are reducing cotton acres and increasing the corn. And that’s maybe another case of mutualism: growers take advantage of skyrocketing corn prices and the cotton inventory chain takes a deep breath, then purges itself to some extent. We think. We hope.

But corn is not the least expensive crop to grow. It takes a lot of water, and thousands and thousands of tons of nitrogen fertilizer. (The Indians used to plant maize by putting a dead fish in with each seed to fertilize it. These guys were the original eco-specialists.) The price of natural gas has gone down for nitrogen fertilizer manufacturers, but increased demand may keep farmer prices where they are. High.

And of course, the cotton infrastructure will take a direct hit. Among other things, cotton seed companies will sell less seed, consultants will scout fewer acres and gins will gin less cotton.

Such is life in the commodities game. At some point you can count on growers saying they are getting back into cotton due to the crash in corn prices. (In fact, they said it before planting the 2006 crop.) It’s called equilibrium, and eventually everything finds it. But until then, pass the corn hooch.

Leave a Reply

Market Analysis Stories
don shurley
Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: Prices Slip Under Pressure

August 15, 2016

The sudden jump in cotton prices was recently referred to as “Christmas in July.” Well, the new wears off eventually – even for Christmas gifts.

Market Analysis

Bears Impact Market, But Long Term Still Bullish

August 22, 2016

The near term technical perspective for the cotton market has turned a bit bearish. But, the longer term outlook remains bullish.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: Feed This Hungry Cotton Market Now!

August 1, 2016

The cotton market is hungry and wants to be fed. It’s time for growers to move their price fixations up and sell it some cotton!

Market Analysis

Mother Nature Now in Charge of the Market

July 24, 2016

At this point in the crop production year, be assured that Mother Nature will still have the major say with respect to cotton prices.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: USDA Turns the Bulls Loose

July 18, 2016

Say it again: Technicals are the leading indicator of fundamentals; they kept telling us higher prices were coming.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: It’s Christmas in July!

July 13, 2016

The calendar says July. But for cotton growers, it may as well be “Merry Christmas.”

Market Analysis

Watching Bulls, Bears and Fundamentals

July 11, 2016

Fundamentals rule in the long run, but technicals provide the roadmap. Just be sure to keep an eye on the bulls and bears.

Around The Gin
Product News

ChemChina/Syngenta Deal Gets U.S. Foreign Investment Approval

August 22, 2016

ChemChina and Syngenta have received a key clearance for the proposed consolidation of the companies.

Product News

Enlist Cotton Trait Earns Full Export Approval

August 10, 2016

Cotton varieties containing Dow AgroSciences’ Enlist trait now have full export approval in key countries.

Product News

Spray Equipment Offer Helps Maximize On-Target Applications

August 3, 2016

A new spray technology equipment offer can help growers participating in Roundup Ready PLUS Crop Management Solutions upgrade their sprayers to maximize on-target applications.

Product News

EPA Allows Sale and Use of Existing Belt Inventory

August 2, 2016

The U.S. EPA’s Environmental Appeals Board has upheld an earlier decision to cancel registration for Bayer's insecticide Belt, but is allowing sales of existing stocks to growers for use.

Product News

Indigo Launches Water Efficiency Product for Cotton

July 26, 2016

Boston-based research firm Indigo has launched its first commercial product – Indigo Cotton – which helps improve the cotton plant’s water use efficiency.

Product News

Enlist Technology Provides Tolerance to Three Key Herbicides

July 13, 2016

The Enlist weed control system will give growers the ability to use three modes of action postemergence in both cotton and soybeans.

Product News

Providing Upland Varieties with Acala-like Quality

July 13, 2016

PhytoGen offers growers several upland cotton varieties with Acala-like fiber quality for added premiums and higher profitability.

Product News

PhytoGen Names Winners in Best Yielder Club Sweepstakes

June 29, 2016

A North Carolina cotton grower was named grand prize winner in the 2016 PhytoGen Best Yielder Club sweepstakes.

Latest News
Market Analysis

Bears Impact Market, But Long Term Still Bullish

August 22, 2016

The near term technical perspective for the cotton market has turned a bit bearish. But, the longer term outlook remains bullish.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: Prices Slip Under Pressure

August 15, 2016

The sudden jump in cotton prices was recently referred to as “Christmas in July.” Well, the new wears off eventually – even for Christmas gifts.

Market Analysis

Market Holds On in Face of Neutral Report

August 14, 2016

USDA’s August cotton reports were neutral-to-supportive, keeping the 70-78 cent trading range in place as the major trading channel.

Market Analysis

Market Strong, But Looking for Answers on China, India

August 5, 2016

This market has 80 cents written all over it. But it’s also calling for a closer look at reported cotton stocks in China and India.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: Feed This Hungry Cotton Market Now!

August 1, 2016

The cotton market is hungry and wants to be fed. It’s time for growers to move their price fixations up and sell it some cotton!

Market Analysis

Mother Nature Now in Charge of the Market

July 24, 2016

At this point in the crop production year, be assured that Mother Nature will still have the major say with respect to cotton prices.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: USDA Turns the Bulls Loose

July 18, 2016

Say it again: Technicals are the leading indicator of fundamentals; they kept telling us higher prices were coming.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: It’s Christmas in July!

July 13, 2016

The calendar says July. But for cotton growers, it may as well be “Merry Christmas.”

Market Analysis

Watching Bulls, Bears and Fundamentals

July 11, 2016

Fundamentals rule in the long run, but technicals provide the roadmap. Just be sure to keep an eye on the bulls and bears.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: A Fun Week of Bulls, Bears and Brexit

July 5, 2016

The cotton market experienced a fun, exciting week as trading focused on strong bullish and bearish fundamentals – and little to no impact from Brexit.

Market Analysis

Shurley: Acreage Numbers Could Challenge Range-Bound Prices

July 1, 2016

In light of the June 30 USDA acres planted numbers, it would have to be considered good news if cotton’s “range bound” prices can remain at or above 64 cents.

Market Analysis

Market Fundamentals Positive, but Not Yet Bullish

June 20, 2016

July prices are still bumping into resistance. But there are enough positive fundamentals in the market to provide a bit of bullish hope.

Market Analysis

Shurley on Cotton: Thoughts Ahead of the Acreage Report

June 16, 2016

There’s usually speculation on the June USDA Acreage number and how it might compare to the March Prospective Plantings number. So far, it's all quiet.

Market Analysis

Commodity and Mill Actions Pushing Cotton Higher

June 10, 2016

It was a pretty good week for cotton, as fund money continued to flow to all commodities, and mills began to ease their price expectations higher.

Market Analysis

Mills, Speculators and Weather Driving Cotton Prices

June 7, 2016

Mother Nature’s recent whims are driving new money into cotton, as mills come to grips with rising prices and price fixations, which fuel buying by hedge fund long speculators.