New Questions Facing Thrips Management

Scott Stewart wants growers and consultants to remember that thrips control matters, especially with some potential issues with thrips management raising questions among researchers.

“I’ve looked at a lot of data in Tennessee, Arkansas and Mississippi,” said Stewart, University of Tennessee Extension entomologist, speaking to a group of consultants in Memphis. “Consistently, we are getting a minimum of 100 pounds yield increase by managing thrips, and, in some cases, you might be able to argue that it’s 200 pounds. It’s too big of a risk to not manage thrips.”

Over the past eight to 10 years, thrips control in cotton has shifted almost entirely to insecticide seed treatments. Long-time cotton growers may always lament the loss of Temik, but the seed treatments have brought their own positives to cotton production.

“We are heavily reliant on seed treatments, primarily imidacloprid and thiamethoxam at a rate of .375 mg of active ingredient,” said Stewart. “Historically, if you look at the data, Temik was better than the seed treatments at reducing the numbers of thrips and providing longer residual control. But it wasn’t reflected in yield. The seed treatments have done just as well at protecting yield, and historically, the difference between thiamethoxam and imidacloprid has been negligible.”

Although thrips management is still in good shape, Stewart points out that some potential control issues have surfaced over the past few seasons – issues that he and other entomologists are continuing to examine closely in their research work. The focus is on three potential reasons for diminished performance – potential plant damage and interference from preemergence herbicide applications, possible degradation of the active ingredients by soil microbes, and decreased susceptibility of thrips to the seed treatments.

“During this timeframe, growers started battling glyphosate-resistant pigweed and increased their use of preemergence herbicides,” said Stewart. “We started seeing more herbicide injury to young plants, which hurt the vigor. And if we also had thrips hurting the vigor, we were getting a double whammy in the field.

“There are definitely times when preemergence herbicides hold back the cotton. They can cause delay and stunting. If you get thrips on top of that, there’s definitely going to be some negative impact.”

The possibility that soil microbes have evolved to the point where they can metabolize the seed treatments and lessen their effectiveness is not unprecedented, pointed out Stewart. It’s happened before with Temik and with several herbicides.

To find out, soil samples were collected and examined. The results to date show that the microbes are having some impact on the active ingredients, but not enough to affect performance.

The real concern lies with diminished performance, and that’s where the majority of testing will focus this year.

“These seed treatments are neonicotinoid insecticides, and those chemistries are used on virtually every crop,” stated Stewart. “Almost 100 percent of our cotton and corn acres in the Mid-South and probably 50 to 75 percent of our soybeans are getting treatments. We are using these products a lot, and there is potential for selection pressure and resistance.

“It’s not likely that thrips have developed resistance, since there are so many hosts for them,” he added. “But whatever it is, it seems to be consistently impacting thiamethoxam more than imidacloprid.”

The primary problem seems to be with tobacco thrips, which make up roughly 81 percent of the thrips population in cotton. Testing was somewhat limited last year, says Stewart, but will expand this year throughout multiple Cotton Belt states.

“We’ll all be involved in trying to figure out how widespread and severe this problem may be,” he said.

So how should growers approach thrips control this year?

“It’s hard to fix a thrips problem after you have it,” stated Stewart. “You have to be proactive.”

He suggests using imidacloprid as the primary seed treatment and adding a foliar application at the 1-2 leaf stage. Imidacloprid still provides enough protection that one foliar application should be sufficient in most circumstances.

For growers who use thiamethoxam, Stewart suggests treating the cotton proactively with a foliar insecticide. Plan for at least two scheduled applications – the first 4-5 days after emergence, followed by the second application a week later. A third application may be needed if thrips populations are high.

“You’ll have to be very aggressive,” he said. “If you are making multiple applications, you might want to consider using Radiant for the second application. And there are a couple of reasons why.

“If you start with acephate, it’s inexpensive and works pretty well on tobacco thrips. But it leaves the Western flower thrips, and they’re harder to kill with acephate. If you come back with Radiant, you can take out those Western flower thrips and are less likely to flare a problem like spider mites or aphids.”

Leave a Reply

Cotton Production Stories
Planting

Cover Crop Costs Recovered on Rolling Plains Cotton

December 28, 2016

Irrigated cotton producers on the Texas Rolling Plains could potentially be reaping more dollars per acre if they include a cover crop on their continuous cotton.

Cotton Production

Dates Set for Required Pesticide Training in Georgia

January 19, 2017

Before applying new auxin herbicides to dicamba- or 2,4-D-tolerant cotton and soybean varieties, growers and applicators in Georgia will be required to attend one of six pesticide training sessions.

Harvest

Cotton Looks Promising in Texas’ Rolling and High Plains

October 19, 2016

Good late-summer rains improved conditions for cotton in the Rolling and High Plains regions of Texas and likely mean an above-average crop for 2016.

Harvest

Possible Storm Impact on North Carolina Cotton

October 11, 2016

NC State specialists offer guidelines for making harvest decisions on cotton acres impacted by tropical storm Matthew.

Harvest

NCC Urges Cotton Quality Maintenance Following Rain Events

October 7, 2016

Growers and ginners are urged to follow proper guidelines to preserve cotton crop quality following Hurricane Matthew and other rain events at harvest.

Harvest

2016 Mid-South Defoliation Guide Now Online

September 9, 2016

The 2016 edition of the Mid-South Cotton Defoliation Guide is complete and now available online.

Harvest

Managing Proper Defoliation Timing

September 1, 2016

Proper defoliation planning helps protect yields. But it’s just as important when it comes to maximizing fiber quality.

Around The Gin
Product News

Enlist Duo Herbicide Registered for Use on Enlist Cotton

January 13, 2017

The U.S. EPA has registered Enlist Duo herbicide for use on Enlist cotton varieties, beginning in 2017.

Product News

Data Show Yield Gains from Indigo Cotton in 2016

January 9, 2017

Data collected from 2016 trials show that Indigo Cotton – a seed treatment based on naturally occurring, in-plant microbes to help increase water use efficiency – led to yield improvements on testing acres, including an 11% average yield increase in West Texas.

Product News

FiberMax and Stoneville Release New Varieties for 2017

January 9, 2017

Cotton growers searching to match the right variety the right field now have two new FiberMax varieties and two new Stoneville varieties to consider for 2017.

Product News

PhytoGen Rolls Out Seven New Enlist Varieties for 2017

January 5, 2017

PhytoGen is releasing seven new cotton varieties with the Enlist cotton trait and WideStrike 3 Insect Protection for the 2017 growing season.

Product News

Do You Qualify for the Stoneville Legacy Club?

January 3, 2017

Signup is now open for the new Stoneville Legacy Club, celebrating both the rich history of Stoneville and the generational wisdom of the growers who make 3-plus bales.

Product News

FiberMax Celebrates Growers Who Maximize Dryland Production

December 30, 2016

The new FiberMax Maximizer Club celebrates growers who produce great dryland cotton yields, and signup for the club is now open.

Product News

EPA Registers Engenia Herbicide from BASF

December 21, 2016

The EPA has registered Engenia herbicide for control of more than 200 broadleaf weeds, including glyphosate-resistant weeds, in dicamba-tolerant cotton and soybeans.

Product News

Growers Impressed with First PhytoGen WideStrike 3 Enlist Variety

December 19, 2016

The first growers to plant PhytoGen brand PHY 490 W3FE say the germplasm and technology combination helped them work smarter and increase cotton production.

Latest News
Cotton Production

Dates Set for Required Pesticide Training in Georgia

January 19, 2017

Before applying new auxin herbicides to dicamba- or 2,4-D-tolerant cotton and soybean varieties, growers and applicators in Georgia will be required to attend one of six pesticide training sessions.

Planting

Cover Crop Costs Recovered on Rolling Plains Cotton

December 28, 2016

Irrigated cotton producers on the Texas Rolling Plains could potentially be reaping more dollars per acre if they include a cover crop on their continuous cotton.

Cotton Production

EPA Registers Dicamba Formulation for Use On Dicamba Tolerant Crops

November 9, 2016

The EPA has registered Monsanto's XtendiMax with Vapor Grip technology - a new, low volatility dicamba formulation - for use in weed control programs in cotton and soybean crops engineered for dicamba tolerance.

Harvest

Cotton Looks Promising in Texas’ Rolling and High Plains

October 19, 2016

Good late-summer rains improved conditions for cotton in the Rolling and High Plains regions of Texas and likely mean an above-average crop for 2016.

Harvest

Possible Storm Impact on North Carolina Cotton

October 11, 2016

NC State specialists offer guidelines for making harvest decisions on cotton acres impacted by tropical storm Matthew.

Planting

Increasing Planter Capacity: Go Faster or Wider?

October 11, 2016

New technologies are giving growers more options to speed up planting. The best solution is the one better suited for your field shape and size.

Harvest

NCC Urges Cotton Quality Maintenance Following Rain Events

October 7, 2016

Growers and ginners are urged to follow proper guidelines to preserve cotton crop quality following Hurricane Matthew and other rain events at harvest.

Harvest

2016 Mid-South Defoliation Guide Now Online

September 9, 2016

The 2016 edition of the Mid-South Cotton Defoliation Guide is complete and now available online.

Harvest

Managing Proper Defoliation Timing

September 1, 2016

Proper defoliation planning helps protect yields. But it’s just as important when it comes to maximizing fiber quality.

Harvest

Is Cotton Turning Too Soon?

August 31, 2016

Mid-South cotton normally “turns,” or reaches senescence, during the early weeks of the football season. This year, there are reasons why that change is already appearing before the first kickoff.

Harvest

Harvesting Bottom Line Advantages

August 11, 2016

Options such as co-ownership and sharing of farm equipment are helping provide financial advantages to growers across the country.

Harvest

Proper Timing of Harvest Aids Focus of New Webcast

July 25, 2016

A new webcast explaining proper timing and use of harvest aids has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

Cotton Production

Lessons from the 2011 Drought

July 7, 2016

Years of drought in the Southwest have changed the way cotton producers think about water management.

Cotton Production

More Impact on Cotton Yields from Rotation, Cover Crops

July 6, 2016

After eight years of research on cotton crop tillage, Dr. Paul DeLaune is convinced that yields are impacted more by the cover crop and/or rotation.

Production Outlook / Acreage

USDA: 10 Million Cotton Acres Planted in 2016

July 1, 2016

USDA’s first acreage report for 2016 shows that U.S. cotton growers have planted 10 million acres in 2016 – a 17% jump above last year's plantings.