Researchers Seek the Best Seeding Rate for Yield Potential

Growers who have been around long enough don’t need to be reminded just how much the cost of a bag of seed has risen in recent years.

As seed companies pack more research and genetic advancements into each seed, the costs have skyrocketed. As recently as 1996, a 10 pound bag of seed could be sold at retail for as little as $7. By 2010, the same size bag could go for as much as $70, a ten-fold increase in less than two decades. Growers and subsequently researchers across the Cotton Belt have taken notice.

“As far as plant populations, many studies have been done on this throughout the Cotton Belt,” says Dr. Ed Barnes, director of agricultural and environmental research at Cotton Incorporated.

One such study that Barnes has kept an eye on has been conducted by researcher Sam Wang, a cropping systems specialist with the University of Arizona, in conjunction with Dr. Randy Norton. Wang conducted his studies at the Maricopa Agriculture Center in Maricopa, AZ.

Wang set out to at least narrow the range of recommended planting rates for growers in his area. The commonly accepted range of 20,000 to 55,000 plants per acre left a lot of room for either over- or under-population.

“We wanted to give them a more narrow range so that they could really focus on what works best,” says Wang. “Normally, growers we talked with would plant too high or too dense when left with such a wide recommended range.”

Wang chose two very specific varieties for his research – Deltapine DP 0949 B2RF and Stoneville ST 4498B2RF. The idea was to study varieties that have notably different plant architecture.

“The DP 0949 B2RF grows tall and compact, while the ST 4498B2RF has more of a bushy shape,” says Wang. “We wanted to see how these different types of plants respond to different rates of plant population.”

Wang used four 40-inch wide rows and 40 feet long plots at varying rates of density at his fields in Maricopa. The plots were in sandy loam soils, and all were furrow irrigated. Tests were conducted at nine different plant population rates, ranging from 5,000 plants per acre to 70,000 plants per acre.

Given these conditions, Wang varied his plant density per acre with both varieties, and found a noteworthy pattern. Typically, yields rose at a stable rate as density rose from 5,000 plants per acre to 30,000 plants per acre and up to 35,000 plants per acre. Wang says that once populations rose past 35,000 plants per acre, the lint yield plateaued. The similar lint yield held as plant population increased, until the plants per acre rose past 50,000. At this point, the data reflected a clear decline in yield per acre.

In the first year of the study’s existence, Wang enlisted a local farmer at Marana, AZ, who conducted two properly replicated and randomized trials using PHY 499WRF in one field and PHY 375WRF in another, on a larger, working scale. Those results corroborated Wang’s findings that cotton at 35,000 plants per acre yielded better than 29,000 plants per acre or 42,000 plants per acre.

That data supported the long-held belief that overpopulation can strain an individual plant’s ability to yield to its full potential. This is especially true in less than ideal soil scenarios.

“For variable rate planting, a general strategy is to lower planting rates in the weaker soil types for two reasons,” says Barnes. “First, you want to lower plant to plant competition for limited water and nutrients. Secondly, there is less to risk in lower yield soils. That is, if you do not get a good stand in a soil that will only yield 0.5 bales per acre on a good day, that will not be as big a problem as getting a poor stand on a field that has a three bale per acre yield potential.”

Wang points out that a related benefit to lower plant populations is uniformity within a given field. He focused much of his study during this research on the performance of individual plants.

“It’s consistent with ecological principles of plant population, when the plant density is low, the variation among the plants is low,” says Wang. “So you have plants in a field that are all a similar size. When this happens, you have about 60 percent of the plants that are above average size, meaning the majority of the plants are contributing to lint yield.

“Conversely, in a high density plot, you get some plants with a large size, but about 60 percent of the plants are smaller than average. This means that there are a lot of plants in that field that are not being very productive. Their contributions to yield are very small,” says Wang.

Both Wang and Barnes recognize that there are other variables that may come into play when a grower is deciding how densely to populate a given field. In those instances where a cotton producer may opt for a more sparsely populated field, Barnes says growers should keep emergence rates in mind.

“The low end of that commonly accepted range of 20,000 assumes you will have 20,000 plants that emerge,” says Barnes. “So, you would want a higher seeding rate of at least 25,000 to make sure you have that many plants. Also, this low rate assumes the plants are evenly distributed. It does not apply to skippy stands.”

Another factor to consider when choosing a plant population rate is the maturity rate of a given crop. Growers in northern regions of the Cotton Belt who require a shorter-maturing variety should consider planting a higher seeding rate.

“Dense populations – usually involving 15 inch or tighter row spacings – do typically result in an earlier crop,” says Barnes.

So, while other factors will come into play when deciding how densely to populate a field, researchers like Wang and Barnes are giving growers a better idea of how to maximize their own yield potential. At the very least, Wang hopes his research has helped narrow the wide range of options growers face when contemplating plant populations.

“We want to help them save on their input costs and have better yields, for sure, but we want them to have a better idea of how density affects individual plant performance, too,” says Wang. “We wanted to narrow that range so a farmer won’t go too low or too high.”

Leave a Reply

News Stories
News

Beltwide Showcases Solutions for Cotton Production

November 28, 2016

The Beltwide Cotton Conferences annually bring the industry together to review the latest in research and innovations. For the 2017 meeting, some discussions may raise more questions in need of answers.

Product News

Valent Introduces Valor EZ Herbicide for 2017

December 1, 2016

Valent has introduced Valor EZ Herbicide as a residual herbicide partner for the new next generation seed systems in cotton and soybeans.

News

Webcast Focuses on Bollworm Management in Bt Cotton

November 30, 2016

A new webcast focusing on bollworm management in Bt cotton has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

Product News

Wearable Cotton Sensors Developed

November 29, 2016

Conductive cotton fabrics have been developed into flexible wearable sensors, creating new options for cotton textiles.

News

Bayer May Sell Some Cotton and Canola Assets in Monsanto Deal

November 29, 2016

Bayer expects to sell some cotton and canola seed businesses to help allay antitrust concerns about its acquisition of Monsanto.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Key Factors Impacting Leaf Grade Values

November 28, 2016

A new webcast explaining the impact of leaf pubescence on fiber quality has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

AR State Plant Board Sets Nov. 21 Hearing on New Dicamba Formulation

November 14, 2016

The Arkansas State Plant Board will host a public comment hearing session regarding XtendiMax with Vapor Grip Technology – the newly-approved, low volatility dicamba product – on Nov. 21 in Little Rock.

Around The Gin
Product News

Valent Introduces Valor EZ Herbicide for 2017

December 1, 2016

Valent has introduced Valor EZ Herbicide as a residual herbicide partner for the new next generation seed systems in cotton and soybeans.

Product News

Wearable Cotton Sensors Developed

November 29, 2016

Conductive cotton fabrics have been developed into flexible wearable sensors, creating new options for cotton textiles.

Product News

Dow AgroSciences, U.S. Farmers Disagree with Proposal to Revoke Chlorpyrifos Tolerances

November 10, 2016

Dow AgroSciences is standing by the safety of proper use of chlorpyrifos, in the face of EPA’s release of a pre-publication copy of the Notice of Data Availability related to its assessment of human health risks associated with the insecticide.

Product News

Advanced Germplasm and Traits Help Growers Thrive in Cotton

November 7, 2016

PhytoGen offers options to improve fiber quality and control weeds, helping growers to out-best their best and thrive in cotton.

Product News

EPA Sets Comment Period for Enlist Duo Label Expansion

November 2, 2016

The U.S. EPA has set a public comment period until December 1 for proposed label amendments for Enlist Duo, which would allow use on Enlist cotton and extend product use on all Enlist crops to 19 other states.

Product News

Helping Cotton Growers Be Good Neighbors

November 1, 2016

Good fences make good neighbors. But these days, on-target herbicide applications also can help make growers good neighbors.

Product News

Americot Offers New XtendFlex Cotton Varieties for 2017

October 28, 2016

In 2017, Americot will offer three new Bollgard II XtendFlex varieties and one new XtendFlex only variety to cotton growers.

Product News

Bayer Delivers Right Combinations for Performance and Profit

October 27, 2016

The extensive economic data documenting earnings from FiberMax and Stoneville varieties helps make the Bayer lineup the first stop for variety decisions.

Latest News
News

Webcast Focuses on Bollworm Management in Bt Cotton

November 30, 2016

A new webcast focusing on bollworm management in Bt cotton has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Bayer May Sell Some Cotton and Canola Assets in Monsanto Deal

November 29, 2016

Bayer expects to sell some cotton and canola seed businesses to help allay antitrust concerns about its acquisition of Monsanto.

News

Beltwide Showcases Solutions for Cotton Production

November 28, 2016

The Beltwide Cotton Conferences annually bring the industry together to review the latest in research and innovations. For the 2017 meeting, some discussions may raise more questions in need of answers.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Key Factors Impacting Leaf Grade Values

November 28, 2016

A new webcast explaining the impact of leaf pubescence on fiber quality has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

China to Remain Key Player in Cotton Market and Trade Scenarios

November 16, 2016

China will continue to be a key player in the cotton market following the recent U.S. Presidential election. But, the new administration’s policy on China trade could significantly impact U.S. agricultural exports.

News

AR State Plant Board Sets Nov. 21 Hearing on New Dicamba Formulation

November 14, 2016

The Arkansas State Plant Board will host a public comment hearing session regarding XtendiMax with Vapor Grip Technology – the newly-approved, low volatility dicamba product – on Nov. 21 in Little Rock.

News

Cotton Highlights from November WASDE Report

November 9, 2016

The November WASDE report shows slightly higher estimates for U.S. cotton production and for domestic and global ending stocks, while mill use, exports and consumption numbers remain steady.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Nutrient Testing and Management Practices

November 8, 2016

A new webcast focusing on ways to monitor and maintain sufficient nutrient levels in cotton has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Webcast Focuses on Reducing Pigweed Seed in Soil Seedbank

October 27, 2016

A new webcast focusing on ways to reduce pigweed seed in the soil seedbank has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Input Needed for 2017 Acreage Survey

October 25, 2016

Answer three simple online questions to help give Cotton Grower an accurate look at next season for our 2017 Cotton Acreage Survey, coming in January.

News

Webcast Focuses on Nutrient Management in Cotton

October 25, 2016

A new webcast focusing on nutrient management in cotton has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Global Cotton Demand, Consumption on the Rise

October 19, 2016

Cotton consumption will be the highest in six years, predicted NCC President Gary Adams during a recent meeting in Lubbock.

News

Webcast Offers Tips to Minimize Pest Management Impact on Bees

October 12, 2016

A new webcast to help growers and beekeepers work together to minimize conditions that may impact pollinators has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Cotton Highlights from October WASDE Report

October 12, 2016

The October WASDE report shows lower estimates for U.S. production and for domestic and global ending stocks, but increases for U.S. exports and world trade.

News

Registration, Meeting Info for 2017 Beltwide Conferences Now Online

September 30, 2016

Information about registration and hotel reservations for the 2017 Beltwide Cotton Conferences in Dallas is now available on the conference website.