Results In for NC On-Farm Cotton Variety Evaluation
By Guy Collins and Keith Edmisten, North Carolina State University
Although 2017 brought its share of challenges, this has been a year that our growers have badly needed for a while. We are thankful to harvest high yields in most areas of our cotton-producing areas while avoiding any majorly destructive weather during the fall months.
The yield results are now available from the 2017 On-Farm Cotton Variety Evaluation Program.
This program was once again a huge success in 2017, thanks to the substantial support from the NC Cotton Producers Association, NCDA&CS, NC State University, our seed companies and Cotton Incorporated. This program was only made possible through their leadership and support, and the significant effort from our county agents, consultants, and cooperating growers through implementing this program in 15 trials across the state. The contributions of all involved are much appreciated, and will have significant impact on our growers’ bottom line as we look forward to 2018.
As mentioned before, this on-farm program consists of the most widely-adapted and best-fit varieties for NC cotton growers as determined by our leading seed companies. It is always advised that variety decisions be based on multi-environment and multi-year replicated data in order to identify varieties with a high degree of stability (strong performance across a wide range of environmental conditions and years). As a standard practice, it is always wise for growers to choose several varieties and position those varieties in environments where they are likely to perform competitively.
It is also advised that growers observe data from both the on-farm program and NCSU Official Variety Trials (OVT), which will be available very soon. Both programs serve as platforms for effective evaluation of variety performance, but are different in several regards. One of the primary strengths of the on-farm program is the vast number of environments that are effectively captured in a given season. However, OVT can accommodate many more varieties than we can effectively evaluate in an on-farm trial, and many of our seed companies have several competitive varieties available for NC producers – many of which are evaluated in OVT. Together, the on-farm and OVT programs collectively offer growers a complete platform for making variety decisions.
Within the third year of this program alone, the on-farm program again has clearly demonstrated that variety selection is one of the most important decisions a grower can make that will significantly impact their profitability in a given year. Depending on the degree of variety selection error, the 2017 on-farm trials clearly illustrated that producers could lose an average of $130 to $263 per acre due to improper variety selection, with a potential statewide economic value of $47,450,000 to $95,995,000!! Keep in mind that these figures are based on performance of the best varieties from each brand, therefore a producer could do much worse than this by choosing a less competitive variety.
Variety performance information will be discussed in much greater detail during the upcoming winter meetings (look for meeting dates/locations for your county at your local county extension office or on the NCSU Cotton Portal Website). Additionally, your local county agent is an excellent resource for variety selection, so please contact them for your local trial results. They will be happy to share those results with you.
Additionally, the NC Cotton Variety Performance Calculator , launched in early 2016, is an excellent resource for growers to use to make customized variety comparisons based on geographical region, yield environment, years or multi-years, and trial type. The calculator is now updated with lint yields of the 2017 on-farm trials, and will be updated with HVI and OVT data as soon as those results are in.
This slide offers a very general summary of variety performance across the state. Variety performance data will be dissected in much greater detail and by region in the upcoming winter meetings. This year especially, growers should focus more on factors such as stability characteristics, regional performance, positioning varieties in specific types of environments, and understanding yield limiting factors such as drought stress during early bloom and potential impacts of bollworms, versus focusing on the overall variety ranking.
There are several ways to approach and observe 2017 variety performance data, and this will be explained thoroughly during meeting season. Therefore, growers might want to hold off on making any definite variety decisions until these various approaches can be discussed thoroughly during winter meetings.
In this slide, varieties are ranked in descending order according to average yield across all trials in the analysis. Varieties with yields highlighted in green indicate that yields were above average across locations. The percentage of trials in which a variety performed at the top, within the top 2, within the top 3, and most importantly within the statistically highest-yielding group are also shown. It is important to note that lint yields were thankfully higher than normal this year, which is great for our state. However, this leaves us with little assessment of variety performance in droughty conditions for brand new varieties especially.
Additionally, yield limiting factors such as bollworms clearly impacted variety performance in a few places this year, and this will be discussed during the winter meetings. As mentioned earlier, individual trial results can be obtained from your local county agent and in the variety calculator. Results for OVT and fiber quality will be available soon. Growers are also encouraged however to observe multi-location and multi-year data before making variety decisions.
Again, results from the on-farm program along with OVT will be discussed in much greater detail during the upcoming winter meetings, so be sure to attend one near you. This program was a huge success again in 2017 due to the efforts of all involved, and we look forward to another year of this program in 2018!