facebook_pixel

Examining Loan Program and Rate Changes for 2017

The marketing assistance loan (MAL) is an important tool used by many producers and marketing associations in cotton pricing and risk management.

In addition to research and farmer education, I teach courses in commodity marketing and agricultural policy, and I tell my students that the key to basic understanding of the “Loan Program” is to remember that it’s just another way to store the crop and price it later. The crop is stored in an approved facility, the producer receives the Loan Rate, and the crop is pledged as collateral for the loan. The crop is eventually sold on the cash/spot market and the loan and any storage and interest charges paid.  So, the Marketing Loan is storage, but receiving some money/cash flow (the Loan Rate) up front.

Prior to the 2014 Farm Bill for as long as I can remember, the Loan Rate has been 52 cents per pound. Under the 2014 Farm Bill, the Loan Rate is now allowed to “float” between 45 and 52 cents. The Loan Rate is now the average Adjusted World Price (AWP) for the most recently completed two marketing years, but not to exceed 52 cents and not less than 45 cents.

For each year of the 2014 Farm Bill thus far, the average AWP has been above 52 cents, so the 52 cent maximum for the Loan Rate has held. For the 2017 crop, however, the Loan Rate will be 49.49 cents – 2.51 cents less than 2016. This was the average AWP for the 2014-2015 crop years. The Loan Rate has to be announced by October 1 of the year prior to planting, and the 2016 marketing year not completed at that time, so there is a 1-year lag in the calculation.

What are the implications of this?  First of all, realize that cotton stored in the Loan will eventually be sold on the cash/spot market. The MAL acts only as a cash flow tool. The lower Loan Rate means less cash flow up front. The 49.49 cents is the “Base” rate for Color 41, 4 Leaf, and Staple 34. There are also adjustments from this amount (differences) for better or less fiber quality.

Loan differences, also referred to as loan premiums and discounts, are determined based on actual cash/spot market prices paid for various cotton quality factors for the prior three years. Although the Base loan rate may change depending on what the AWP does, that has no direct impact on loan differences. Following are a few comparisons of loan premiums (+) and discounts (-) for the 2017 crop compared to last year’s crop.

Comparison of Selected Fiber Quality Premiums and Discounts,

2016 and 2017 Upland Cotton Loan Schedule

2016 Crop 2017 Crop
31-3/35 +290 +255
31-3/36 +395 +375
32-3/35 +5 -10
42-4/34 -205 -250
EM* Level 1 -445 -455
Micronaire 5.0-5.2 -230 -230
Uniformity 83-83.9 +15 +15
Strength 30-30.9 +25 +30
* Excluding bark in TX, NM, OK, and KS and excluding Prep in all locations.

 

With the lower Loan Rate for the 2017 crop, the question might also be asked how this would impact any LDP (Loan Deficiency Payment) or MLG (Marketing Loan Gain)? An LDP or MLG is available when the AWP is less than the Loan Rate. Since the Loan Rate is reduced 2.51 cents for the 2017 crop, the AWP will have to be 2.51 cents lower to trigger an LDP/MLG – but this assumes the AWP calculation hasn’t also changed. In fact though, it has.

The AWP (Adjusted World Price) is derived from the A-Index – a proxy for the “World Price.” The A-Index is based on prices for cotton delivered to Far Eastern ports or the “FE Price.” This price is then “adjusted” for transportation costs and fiber quality to arrive at the AWP. For the 2016 crop year, this adjustment was 17.43 cents. For the 2017 crop, this adjustment is less at 17.05 cents.

Taking into account both the drop in the Loan Rate and the reduction in the cost and quality adjustment, the FE Price must now be almost 3 cents lower (2.89 cent lower) to trigger an LDP/MLG. Nearby cotton futures prices are currently about 8 cents below the FE Price. This means an LDP or MLG is not triggered until futures get to approximately 59 cents or less – almost 3 cents lower than what prices would have to have been previously.

2016 Crop 2017 Crop
Loan Rate 52.00 49.49
Add the “adjustment” +17.43 +17.05
FE Price where AWP = Loan Rate 69.43 66.54
Difference between futures and FE -8.00 -8.00
Futures price where AWP = Loan 61.43 58.54

 

The difference between nearby futures and the FE Price can and will vary during the marketing year. At 8 to 9 cents currently, this is on the higher side of what this difference can typically be. If the difference were only 6 cents, for example, there will be an LDP/MLG on the 2017 crop unless futures were below 60 to 61 cents. Regardless, an FE Price below 66.54 is needed to give an AWP less than the Loan Rate of 49.49 cents.

When cotton is stored under the Loan, the producer will have two choices – redemption (repay the loan plus charges or the AWP, whichever is less, and sell the cotton on the spot/cash market) or accept a merchant equity offer. Assuming a 70-cent cash market and the Base loan rate, here’s how a merchant equity pencils out:

2016 2017
Market 70.00 70.00
-Loan Repayment -52.00 -49.49
-Charges* -2.94 -2.94
Equity Payment to Grower 15.06 17.57
Total to the Grower (Loan + Equity) 67.06 67.06
*Charges will vary depending on location and specific situation. For illustration purposes only.

 

A reduction in the Loan Rate for 2017 provides less to the farmer up front. This is made up by higher equity value and payment. All other things being equal, a reduction in the Loan Rate does not impact the total received by the grower.

 

Topics: , ,

Leave a Reply

Market Analysis Stories
Market Analysis

Bears Growling on Harvest and Demand Challenges

October 22, 2017

Although current trading activity represents a bearish price outlook, Dr. O.A. Cleveland still believes the 65 cent price support will hold. . .even though more experts are abandoning that position.

Market Analysis

Examining Loan Program and Rate Changes for 2017

October 9, 2017

Dr. Don Shurley provides an analysis of what changes in the marketing assistance loan for 2017 could mean for cotton growers.

Market Analysis

Prices Still Sideways as Bearish Moods Grow

October 6, 2017

The market is watching weather and waiting for USDA’s October report. But bearish signs are starting to surface in some segments.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: Market in Hang On and Wait Mode

October 1, 2017

Cotton prices are holding without clear direction right now, as the market continues to watch USDA projections and harvest conditions for answers.

Market Analysis

Lower Chinese Stocks, Higher Polyester Prices Offer Market Hope

September 22, 2017

The market is holding steady, thanks again to China. Their Reserve auction has reduced cotton stocks and bumped consumption. And now, polyester prices are rising as the Chinese trim production.

Market Analysis

USDA Spins Market with Record Supply-to-Use Ratio

September 15, 2017

Hurricanes were but a mere hiccup for the world and U.S. crops. Instead, USDA spun some record-setting numbers that left the market dizzy.

Market Analysis

Shurley: Cotton Makes a Hard Landing

September 15, 2017

Following USDA’s September numbers, December cotton seems to have landed back in the 69-cent, pre-Harvey area.

Around The Gin
Product News

Direct-to-Grower Independent Seed Company Launched

October 20, 2017

A new direct-to-growers seed company is entering the market to provide growers with custom-crafted seed offerings delivered to their farm.

Product News

INTL FCStone Offers Online Tool for OTC Hedging Strategies

October 17, 2017

INTL FCStone Markets, LLC has introduced a new online pricing tool that provides users open access to the firm’s structured products pricing portfolio.

Product News

Americot Team Continues to Grow

October 6, 2017

Americot continues to expand the company’s sales and technical support team, with the addition of six new specialists located throughout the Cotton Belt.

Product News

NemaStrike Technology Ready for Nematode Control in 2018

October 6, 2017

Monsanto adds NemaStrike Technology as a new seed treatment solution to control nematode species across the Cotton Belt.

Product News

Americot Adds Three to Regional Sales Force

September 20, 2017

Americot, Inc. has added three new regional representatives to the company’s sales force.

Product News

Enlist One Herbicide Added to Enlist System

September 13, 2017

Dow AgroSciences adds a straight-goods 2,4-D choline herbicide for additional tank-mix flexibility in Enlist crops.

Product News

Elevore Herbicide Registered for Burndown Use

August 30, 2017

Dow AgroSciences’ Elevore herbicide has received federal registration for use in fall and spring burndown programs for cotton, soybeans and corn.

Product News

Stoneville Legacy Club Honors Charter Members

August 24, 2017

The new Stoneville Legacy Club honored 129 growers who recorded average yields of 1,794 lbs/A or higher on at least 20 acres with Stoneville cotton varieties.

Latest News
Market Analysis

Bears Growling on Harvest and Demand Challenges

October 22, 2017

Although current trading activity represents a bearish price outlook, Dr. O.A. Cleveland still believes the 65 cent price support will hold. . .even though more experts are abandoning that position.

Market Analysis

Shurley: October Numbers Not As Expected, But Prices Hold

October 18, 2017

USDA’s October production and supply and demand estimates are like apples – pick and choose and you’ll find some numbers you like...and some you won’t.

Market Analysis

Trying to Read the Market: Bearish, Neutral or Bullish?

October 13, 2017

After finding USDA’s October WASDE report initially bearish and somewhat neutral, cotton prices went mildly bullish thinking about stronger demand and the real size of the U.S. and foreign crops.

Market Analysis

Examining Loan Program and Rate Changes for 2017

October 9, 2017

Dr. Don Shurley provides an analysis of what changes in the marketing assistance loan for 2017 could mean for cotton growers.

Market Analysis

Prices Still Sideways as Bearish Moods Grow

October 6, 2017

The market is watching weather and waiting for USDA’s October report. But bearish signs are starting to surface in some segments.

Market Analysis

Cleveland: Market in Hang On and Wait Mode

October 1, 2017

Cotton prices are holding without clear direction right now, as the market continues to watch USDA projections and harvest conditions for answers.

Market Analysis

Lower Chinese Stocks, Higher Polyester Prices Offer Market Hope

September 22, 2017

The market is holding steady, thanks again to China. Their Reserve auction has reduced cotton stocks and bumped consumption. And now, polyester prices are rising as the Chinese trim production.

Market Analysis

USDA Spins Market with Record Supply-to-Use Ratio

September 15, 2017

Hurricanes were but a mere hiccup for the world and U.S. crops. Instead, USDA spun some record-setting numbers that left the market dizzy.

Market Analysis

Shurley: Cotton Makes a Hard Landing

September 15, 2017

Following USDA’s September numbers, December cotton seems to have landed back in the 69-cent, pre-Harvey area.

Market Analysis

Higher Prices Holding as Winds Keep Blowing

September 10, 2017

An ill wind is blowing amidst the chaotic cotton trading wrought by back to back hurricanes slamming into two of the country’s major cotton producing regions. But which way does the wind blow?

Market Analysis

Post Harvey, 75 Cents Back in Cotton’s Sights

September 2, 2017

It remains to be seen if the greater loss from Harvey will be to cotton quantity or quality. But it likely means a wider trading range, with 75 cents now possible.

Market Analysis

Shurley: Storms and Other Unknowns for September

September 1, 2017

September could be interesting. Loss evaluation from Harvey will still be underway, and all eyes are watching Irma. How will it all impact USDA’s September report…if at all?

Market Analysis

Hurricane Harvey Leaves Several Market Scenarios

September 1, 2017

Following Hurricane Harvey’s rampage through East and Coastal Texas, cotton growers face several possible outcomes based on the level of damage to their fields.

Market Analysis

Market Watching for Harvey’s Impact on U.S. Crop

August 25, 2017

Hurricane Harvey blew prices to triple digit gains on the week. Now, the market will assess crop damage to see if the storm blew up crop projections as well.

Market Analysis

Was USDA Right? U.S. Crop Looking Bigger.

August 18, 2017

The U.S. crop is signaling that it is getting bigger. With nothing more than a good fall, the crop could climb as much as a million bales more than USDA’s August surprise estimate.