2009 U.S. Cotton Outlook: A Report from the Mid-South Farm and Gin Show

We had a dilemma. We had too much nearby cotton but were being tantalized about a potential shortage. We were losing acreage around the world, and no more so than in the United States,” said Allenberg Cotton Company’s CEO Joe Nicosia. “Along those same lines, we had the situation with ethanol — food for fuel. Food for fuel was converting acres to anything that could be used, mainly corn.”

Nicosia’s remarks came at the Ag Update sessions at the U.S. Mid-South Farm & Gin Show in Memphis, Tennessee in late February.

The theme for this year, he said, was avoiding repeated mistakes.

The hope that cotton stocks would fall in 2007/08 remains the same in 2008/09. “Once again, our expectations of a severe draw down in cotton stocks have faded,” Nicosia said. “We’re left with the reality of having larger stocks once again.”

At the beginning of this marketing year, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) estimated that U.S. carryover would be cut in half from around 9 million bales to 4.5 million. But USDA kept raising the number until it reached 7.7 million bales.

“We will have the largest surplus of cotton in 40 years,” said Nicosia. “We began the last two years with export forecasts that again proved to be too optimistic. As we left here last year, prices were fairly high, and yet stocks continued to build. We talked about the problems around the world with India taking much of our market share, but prices continued to go up and reached $1.08 per pound.”

The saying goes, a bull market is always followed by a bigger bear market. And that is exactly what happened in cotton. A year ago, speculators with long forward-contracted positions owned more cotton on paper than actually existed. As they continued to buy, an artificial spike was created. Within two weeks, speculators with profits began to liquidate, sending the cotton market into a free fall. By November, price for the December ‘09 contract on the New York Board of Trade hit a life-of-contract low of 45.25 cents per pound.

In Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) hearings that followed the unusual spike and collapse, the CFTC said it didn’t see any problems that took place during this time because speculators with over-bought positions began to sell. “I found that to be a very interesting observation from someone not involved in the market because at some point in time, when you finally win the game, you get out,” Nicosia said. “Of course the speculators sold when it went to $1.08 because they were the ones who owned everything.”

At the same time speculators were liquidating, index funds that had been pouring money into all commodities began taking it out. Following the crash in cotton prices came the recession, and the repercussions for cotton were immense.

“A new class of investors has emerged, pouring money into index funds as a hedge against inflation,” said Nicosia. “They decided that owning futures and not the commodity — a very, very big distinction — was the way to go.”

Nicosia said no one could have envisioned the economic conditions of today. “We were talking about the conversion to ethanol, commodities prices were skyrocketing and crude oil was moving toward $150 (USD) per barrel,” he explained. “People were worried about running out of about everything.

“Cotton had hopeful prospects, then all of a sudden demand started to fade and it looked like another surplus was going to be inevitable.”

An Olympic Moment

The most devastating factor in the drop in cotton prices has been the monumental collapse of China’s mill use. Between 2000/01 and 2007/08, China’s mill use more than doubled. In this marketing year, it will drop for the first time in 10 years.

“I don’t think it’s just a coincidence that the commodity collapse came at essentially the same time as the Olympics,” said Nicosia. “China had such a huge build up going into the Olympics — for buildings, for roads, for food, for infrastructure — all that climaxed leading up to the Olympics. When the Olympics were over, that was pretty much it.”

“The recession is the driver of cotton demand now. We’ve taken the food for fuel storm and have set it aside,” he continued. “Yet since the seizing up of the financial markets in October, the impact on cotton consumption has been very pronounced.”

Hope, Recovery, Expectations

Nicosia said that, as far as cotton use is concerned, recessions are usually followed by long, sustained recoveries. Demand usually returns to pre-recession highs.

For example, following the 1973 to 1975 recession, fiber demand rose 17% in 1976 and another 2% in 1977. Following the 1981/82 recession, demand rose 21% in 1983 and another 7% in 1984. “In every year after a recession, with the exception of 1980, we had at least a 10% increase in consumption,” said Nicosia.

If there is a positive to the recession and lower acreage, it is that mills stocks are at extremely low levels and the supply pipeline is virtually empty. If demand returns to pre-recession levels, there will be at least a 6 million bale shortfall, according to Nicosia.

Another important element of last year is the resurgence of government involvement in controlling cotton crops. China has begun purchases of 12.5 million bales for the state reserve, added to an old crop reserve of 5 million. “That means they are buying just under 150,000 bales a day for their reserve,” Nicosia said. “That means they are buying just under 1 million bales every week for their reserve. That’s a phenomenal amount of cotton.”

India has been U.S. cotton’s biggest competitor, but India finds itself in a dilemma with national elections and the collapse in world cotton prices. The Indian government is facing the problem of propping up the millions of people involved in the cotton industry, so the government is purchasing cotton directly from farmers through the Cotton Corporation of India, the governmental marketing organization, and the Maharashtra Cotton Federation, a grower cooperative marketing organization, at a high minimum support price.

“Because we had prices pretty high during the year, they set their price high,” said Nicosia. “About the time they did it, world prices collapsed. Now India finds itself in the situation where they either have to go back and lower their price to the farmer — the last thing they want to do with elections coming up — or they have to suck it up and start buying. And that’s what they did.”

India, he predicted, will have to buy between 10 and 12 million bales at prices substantially above the market.

The Over-Supply Solution

In the U.S., the entire 2008 crop has either gone into the loan or sold with the grower collecting loan deficiency payments. But for the long-term health of the industry, only acreage reductions and/or increases in demand will solve the over-supply problems. Some planting intentions reports have pegged U.S. Upland acreage at less than 8 million. Planting intentions from China are showing a 15% to 20% drop in acreage. And China is in an intense food versus fiber fight.

Obviously this crop year in the U.S. begins with enormous uncertainty. What will have to be answered as this year’s crop goes into the ground are two questions: What will the price of cotton have to be for it to increase acres over grains planting? Or how far will grain prices have to fall for cotton at loan value to be more profitable than grains?

“When pessimism is great in the spring and it takes planted acreage away around the world, prices do respond,” Nicosia said.

“If that 5.4 million U.S. carryover goes back to 8 million because the crop comes in at 16 million, or exports drop to 10 million, then here we go again,” he says. But while the demand for cotton seems weak right now, he believes recovery, when it comes, will be sharp. “But if the recession has contracted the demand so greatly and emptied the pipeline so quickly, a rebound will come equally as quick.”

Topics:

Leave a Reply

News Stories
News

Boosting the Value of Cottonseed

August 30, 2016

As cottonseed supply and value grows, the cotton industry continues to fight for the oilseed designation or other legislative options.

News

New Webinar Explains Soil Fertility and Nutrient Management

August 23, 2016

A new webcast on cotton fertility management has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

Product News

ChemChina/Syngenta Deal Gets U.S. Foreign Investment Approval

August 22, 2016

ChemChina and Syngenta have received a key clearance for the proposed consolidation of the companies.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Auxin Herbicide Drift on Non-Tolerant Cotton

August 19, 2016

A new webcast explaining the potential impact of 2,4-D on non-tolerant cotton varieties has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Cotton Highlights from August WASDE Report

August 12, 2016

More positive news for cotton in USDA’s August World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates, including increases in U.S. production and market prices, plus more reductions in global stocks and world production.

Product News

Enlist Cotton Trait Earns Full Export Approval

August 10, 2016

Cotton varieties containing Dow AgroSciences’ Enlist trait now have full export approval in key countries.

News

$1 Billion in Dividend Payouts for FCC

August 9, 2016

With its 2016 dividend payout, Farmers Cooperative Compress of Lubbock will reach the unprecedented milestone of having distributed $1 billion to its producer-owners.

Around The Gin
Product News

ChemChina/Syngenta Deal Gets U.S. Foreign Investment Approval

August 22, 2016

ChemChina and Syngenta have received a key clearance for the proposed consolidation of the companies.

Product News

Enlist Cotton Trait Earns Full Export Approval

August 10, 2016

Cotton varieties containing Dow AgroSciences’ Enlist trait now have full export approval in key countries.

Product News

Spray Equipment Offer Helps Maximize On-Target Applications

August 3, 2016

A new spray technology equipment offer can help growers participating in Roundup Ready PLUS Crop Management Solutions upgrade their sprayers to maximize on-target applications.

Product News

EPA Allows Sale and Use of Existing Belt Inventory

August 2, 2016

The U.S. EPA’s Environmental Appeals Board has upheld an earlier decision to cancel registration for Bayer's insecticide Belt, but is allowing sales of existing stocks to growers for use.

Product News

Indigo Launches Water Efficiency Product for Cotton

July 26, 2016

Boston-based research firm Indigo has launched its first commercial product – Indigo Cotton – which helps improve the cotton plant’s water use efficiency.

Product News

Enlist Technology Provides Tolerance to Three Key Herbicides

July 13, 2016

The Enlist weed control system will give growers the ability to use three modes of action postemergence in both cotton and soybeans.

Product News

Providing Upland Varieties with Acala-like Quality

July 13, 2016

PhytoGen offers growers several upland cotton varieties with Acala-like fiber quality for added premiums and higher profitability.

Product News

PhytoGen Names Winners in Best Yielder Club Sweepstakes

June 29, 2016

A North Carolina cotton grower was named grand prize winner in the 2016 PhytoGen Best Yielder Club sweepstakes.

Latest News
News

Boosting the Value of Cottonseed

August 30, 2016

As cottonseed supply and value grows, the cotton industry continues to fight for the oilseed designation or other legislative options.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Importance of Cotton Physiology

August 26, 2016

A new webcast focusing on the importance of plant properties in cotton research and management has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

New Webinar Explains Soil Fertility and Nutrient Management

August 23, 2016

A new webcast on cotton fertility management has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Cotton Research and Promotion Hall of Fame Adds Four

August 22, 2016

Four honorees make up the 2016 class of Cotton Incorporated’s Cotton Research and Promotion Hall of Fame.

News

New Webcast Focuses on Auxin Herbicide Drift on Non-Tolerant Cotton

August 19, 2016

A new webcast explaining the potential impact of 2,4-D on non-tolerant cotton varieties has been added to the Focus on Cotton online series from the Plant Management Network and Cotton Incorporated.

News

Cotton Highlights from August WASDE Report

August 12, 2016

More positive news for cotton in USDA’s August World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates, including increases in U.S. production and market prices, plus more reductions in global stocks and world production.

News

$1 Billion in Dividend Payouts for FCC

August 9, 2016

With its 2016 dividend payout, Farmers Cooperative Compress of Lubbock will reach the unprecedented milestone of having distributed $1 billion to its producer-owners.

News

Final P.I.E. Tour Brings Western Growers to Texas

August 8, 2016

Eight Western cotton producers will visit cotton and other ag operations in Texas as part of the National Cotton Council’s 2016 Producer Information Exchange Program.

News

Texas A&M Research Provides Science Behind New Cotton Technology

August 2, 2016

The science behind a new commercially-available seed treatment from Indigo Ag stems directly from research started by Dr. Greg Sword, a Texas A&M entomologist.

News

DowDuPont Merger Gains Shareholder Blessing

July 26, 2016

Stockholders of DuPont and The Dow Chemical Company have voted to approve all proposals needed to complete the merger of the two companies, likely in the second half of 2016.

News

Third P.I.E. Tour Takes Southwest Growers to San Joaquin Valley

July 26, 2016

Eleven Southwest cotton producers will visit ag operations in California’s San Joaquin Valley as part of the National Cotton Council’s 2016 Producer Information Exchange Program.

News

Southeast Cotton Producers Visit Mid-South for P.I.E. Tour

July 22, 2016

Thirteen Southeast cotton producers will visit operations in the Mid-South as part of the National Cotton Council’s 2016 Producer Information Exchange Program.

News

Honoring 100 Years of the U.S. Warehouse Act

July 15, 2016

USDA, the cotton industry and other stakeholders are honoring a century of successful partnership with commodity warehouse operators that have made reliable agricultural storage and marketing possible.

News

P.I.E. Tour Brings Mid-South Cotton Producers to the Carolinas

July 13, 2016

Twelve Mid-South cotton producers will visit operations in North and South Carolina as part of the National Cotton Council’s 2016 Producer Information Exchange Program.

News

Cotton Highlights from July WASDE Report

July 12, 2016

USDA’s July World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates report shows increases in anticipated U.S. cotton production and exports, plus reductions in global stocks and world production.