facebook_pixel

Part III: 10 Years of Bt in India

Dr. Kehsav Kranthi is the director of India’s Central Institute for Cotton Research.

The leaf curl virus started to resurface as a major problem in north India, primarily due to the introduction of more than 270 Bt hybrids in north India, most of which were susceptible to the leaf curl virus. Until 2005, 100% of cotton area in the north was under varieties. Now 95% of the area is under hybrids in Punjab and Haryana, while 40% of the area is under hybrids in Rajasthan. Productivity in north India is likely to decline because of the declining potential of hybrids; the emerging problem of leaf curl virus on the new susceptible Bt-hybrids; a high level of susceptibility to sucking pests (straight varieties were resistant); problems with nutrient deficiencies and physiological disorders; and mealybugs, whiteflies and miscellaneous insect problems that are likely to increase.

The tobacco caterpillar, Spodoptera litura, resurfaced as a problem again as predicted, because of the low toxicity of the Cry1Ac toxin on the species. Bollworms started reappearing on Bt cotton. In February 2010, Monsanto, India declared that pink bollworm had developed resistance to Cry1Ac and that only Bollgard-II would be effective thereafter. Resistance monitoring studies at CICR showed that the American bollworm Helicoverpa armigera was also showing incipient tolerance in some parts of India.

The leaf hoppers showed very high levels of resistance of up to 5,000-fold to imidacloprid and other neonicotinoid insecticides in central India. The neonicotinoids were introduced barely a decade ago. Progressive nutrient (macro and micro) depletion due to the source sink relationship because of Bt-cotton after Bt-cotton hybrid cultivation. Bt-cotton hybrids utilize more nutrients and water for higher yields and profits, therefore the soils are getting progressively depleted and need more nutrient recharging.

The cotton crop is showing nutrient deficiency symptoms in many regions, especially in rainfed zones where wilt and leaf-reddening problems are getting more severe over the years. The productivity is maximum in good soils.

With 780 Bt-cotton hybrids, there is confusion all around, with farmers not being able to choose the Bt-hybrids that may be suitable for their soils and farming conditions. A suitable recommendation of proven package of practices, suitability and adaptability of specific hybrids for specific agro ecological sub zones would facilitate further productivity improvement. Lack of such recommendations have resulted in progressive problems and stagnation of production and productivity (560 kg lint/ha in 2007; 524 Kg lint/ha in 2008; 486 Kg lint/ha in 2009; and 506 Kg lint/ha in 2010) despite a steady increase in the area under Bt-cotton (62% in 2007, 73% in 2008, 84% in 2009, and 85% in 2010).

These issues are related to “stewardship” of the technology and have nothing to do with either the Nt technology or biosafety aspects. The issues have been a major concern with farmers since insecticide use is gradually increasing as required for the management of these emerging new insect pests.

The area under Bt cotton has reached above 90% in many parts of the country but farmers are not following the recommended refugia practices. The intensive Bt cultivation and the noncompliance of refugia is likely to hasten resistance development.

The concern needs to be addressed on priority before it is too late. Though very useful in circumventing the problem of labor shortages, the new technology (Roundup Ready-Flex, developed by Monsanto) does not support cotton intercropping with the commonly used intercrops such as pigeonpea, soybean, maize, and jowar, which were cultivated as part of risk aversion or sustenance.

Moreover, reduction in area of intercrops can hasten the development of bollworm resistance to Bt-cotton. But technologies will continue to make their grand entry in the future. Bt cotton is perceived as only the beginning of good days to come. The experiences with the first GM crop of India must now be effectively used to avoid and prevent issues and concerns that Bt cotton faced.

Can India emerge as a global leader of cotton? The answer, from those who know India well, would certainly be in the affirmative. However, such dreams can become realities only if appropriate technology stewardship plans are formulated utilizing the robust native science and knowledge, without resorting to product releases for short-term commercial gains—something that several Indian seed companies have being doing over the past decade.

With the largest acreage of cotton in the world, abundant natural resources, hard-working farmers and world class technologies in use (with new ones on the way), India can emerge as a global leader effortlessly. It is probably only a matter of time for the rest of the world to wait and watch.

Editor’s Note: This is the third of a three-part feature story on the history of Bt cotton in India. Part I appeared in Cotton International’s previous print issue () and Part II appeared in last week’s newsletter ()

Leave a Reply

Seed Varieties Stories
Seed Varieties

Cotton Varieties Eyed in AgriLife High Plains Trials

April 20, 2017

With more producers interested in cotton due to good markets and prices, the Texas A&M AgriLife Extension variety trials are sure to get more attention in the coming weeks and years.

Seed Varieties

Tennessee 2016 Variety Trial Results Now Online

December 28, 2016

The 2016 Tennessee Cotton Variety Trial Results publication is now available online.

Seed Varieties

Mississippi 2016 Variety Trial Results Now Available Online

December 8, 2016

Data for the 2016 Mississippi Cotton Official Variety Trial program and for the On-Farm Cotton Variety Trials is now available online.

Seed Varieties

NC State 2016 On-Farm Fiber Quality Results Now Online

December 2, 2016

Fiber quality results for the 2016 North Carolina On-Farm Cotton Variety Evaluation Program are now available online.

Seed Varieties

Preliminary 2016 Variety Trial Data Available in TN, NC

December 2, 2016

Preliminary variety performance data from 2016 trials in both Tennessee and North Carolina can now be found online.

Seed Varieties

PhytoGen Poised for Breakout Success

December 1, 2016

Varieties like PHY 333 WRF have laid the template for success at PhytoGen. Now, the Enlist trait is poised to bolster that winning formula.

Seed Varieties

Deltapine Varieties Gain Ground in 2016

November 29, 2016

In 2016, farmers across the Cotton Belt flocked to Deltapine varieties featuring the company’s new trait technology.

Around The Gin
Product News

Americot Adds Three to Regional Sales Force

September 20, 2017

Americot, Inc. has added three new regional representatives to the company’s sales force.

Product News

Enlist One Herbicide Added to Enlist System

September 13, 2017

Dow AgroSciences adds a straight-goods 2,4-D choline herbicide for additional tank-mix flexibility in Enlist crops.

Product News

Elevore Herbicide Registered for Burndown Use

August 30, 2017

Dow AgroSciences’ Elevore herbicide has received federal registration for use in fall and spring burndown programs for cotton, soybeans and corn.

Product News

Stoneville Legacy Club Honors Charter Members

August 24, 2017

The new Stoneville Legacy Club honored 129 growers who recorded average yields of 1,794 lbs/A or higher on at least 20 acres with Stoneville cotton varieties.

Product News

Improved Bollworm Management Expected in 2018

August 23, 2017

Southeast Texas cotton farmers should have new tools available in 2018 to better manage bollworms and other potentially damaging pests.

Product News

Maximizer Club Honors Top FiberMax Dryland Growers

August 17, 2017

The FiberMax Maximizer Club honored 121 growers who yielded at least 1,000 lb/A on dryland acres with FiberMax varieties in 2016.

Product News

Monsanto, Valent Expand Roundup Ready PLUS Partnership

August 7, 2017

Monsanto and Valent U.S.A. are expanding their crop protection partnership for the 2018 Roundup Ready PLUS Crop Management Solutions platform.

Product News

New Broadleaf Burndown Option Coming from Dow AgroSciences

July 31, 2017

A new burndown option for tough broadleaf weeds has shown excellent promise in trials across the Mid-South and Midwest.

Latest News
Seed Varieties

Cotton Varieties Eyed in AgriLife High Plains Trials

April 20, 2017

With more producers interested in cotton due to good markets and prices, the Texas A&M AgriLife Extension variety trials are sure to get more attention in the coming weeks and years.

Seed Varieties

High Plains, Rolling Plains Variety Trial Results Available

February 17, 2017

Texas A&M AgriLife Extension agronomists in the High Plains and Rolling Plains have released the results of their large plot, on-farm, replicated cotton variety trials from 2016.

Seed Varieties

Variety Trial Results Reflect 2016 Extremes in East and South TX

January 19, 2017

The Texas A&M AgriLife Extension 2016 Replicated Agronomic Cotton Evaluation trial results from South and East Texas reflect the extremes of the past season.

Seed Varieties

Tennessee 2016 Variety Trial Results Now Online

December 28, 2016

The 2016 Tennessee Cotton Variety Trial Results publication is now available online.

Seed Varieties

Mississippi 2016 Variety Trial Results Now Available Online

December 8, 2016

Data for the 2016 Mississippi Cotton Official Variety Trial program and for the On-Farm Cotton Variety Trials is now available online.

Seed Varieties

NC State 2016 On-Farm Fiber Quality Results Now Online

December 2, 2016

Fiber quality results for the 2016 North Carolina On-Farm Cotton Variety Evaluation Program are now available online.

Seed Varieties

Preliminary 2016 Variety Trial Data Available in TN, NC

December 2, 2016

Preliminary variety performance data from 2016 trials in both Tennessee and North Carolina can now be found online.

Seed Varieties

PhytoGen Poised for Breakout Success

December 1, 2016

Varieties like PHY 333 WRF have laid the template for success at PhytoGen. Now, the Enlist trait is poised to bolster that winning formula.

Seed Varieties

Deltapine Varieties Gain Ground in 2016

November 29, 2016

In 2016, farmers across the Cotton Belt flocked to Deltapine varieties featuring the company’s new trait technology.

Seed Varieties

CROPLAN Making Its Mark in Cotton

November 26, 2016

With proven varieties and technologies, plus an expanding product pipeline, CROPLAN continues to grow its footprint across the Cotton Belt.

Seed Varieties

Bayer’s Seed Brands Consistent, But Not Complacent

November 23, 2016

Bayer’s Stoneville and FiberMax brands continue their high level of success across the Cotton Belt. But new varieties and resources keep them well positioned for more growth.

Seed Varieties

Americot’s Plan: Keep Coming On Strong

November 21, 2016

Americot/NexGen stunned the market with the top planted cotton variety for 2016. And, based on their plan, they’re just getting started.

Seed Varieties

All-Tex, Dyna-Gro Gearing Up for 2017

November 17, 2016

An aggressive lineup of varieties and trait options for 2017 is helping position the All-Tex and Dyna-Gro brands for market expansion.

Seed Varieties

Deltapine Holds Top Spot in 2016 Planted Varieties

September 15, 2016

Deltapine retained the top spot as the top cottonseed brand planted in the U.S. this year. But a strong performance – and the top planted variety – vaulted Americot up the USDA rankings.

Seed Varieties

Variety Maturity Guide Available from MS State

March 8, 2016

A new guide to variety maturity that shows where popular cotton varieties fall on a maturity timeline is now available online from Mississippi State University.