Shurley: New Year Cotton Policy Update
Under the 2014 farm bill (2014-2018 crop years), cotton is not a “covered commodity” and thus not eligible for ARC and PLC. The 2014 farm bill made several changes to cotton that included:
- Cotton is not a covered commodity and not eligible for ARC/PLC
- Cotton base could not be updated or reallocated
- Cotton base became Generic Base
- On a farm (FSN) with Generic Base, acres planted to other crops (covered commodities) up to but not exceeding the amount of Generic Base, are considered Temporary Base of that commodity and eligible for ARC/PLC.
- Cotton’s new “safety net” is STAX.
- The loan rate is the average Adjusted World Price (AWP) for the most recently completed 2 crop years but cannot be less than 45 cents per lb or more than 52 cents.
These changes have put cotton at a risk-management and sometimes net returns (on Generic Base) disadvantage to other crops. STAX has not been as well-accepted by growers as industry leadership would have liked. For the past several years, cotton industry leadership has sought ways to improve cotton’s “safety net.” This effort has largely focused on “cottonseed” and making cottonseed an “other oilseed” under Title I and thus eligible for PLC under the current farm bill. You will recall the request to former Secretary of Agriculture Vilsack for such a designation being denied. Despite that, industry and legislative efforts continued to pursue the cottonseed option.
Not specifically related to the farm bill, but also in an effort to provide assistance, the Cotton Ginning Cost Share Program (CGCS) provided a one-time payment in 2016 based on 2015 acres planted. That payment was $47.44 per acre planted for Southeast producers and subject to a $40,000 limit per person or legal entity. This was seen as a way the Secretary (Vilsack) could provide support without opening up the farm bill and needing legislative approval.
Both the cottonseed PLC option and the CGCS Program have always been seen as a bridge – tools to provide financial support for cotton producers until a new farm bill begins with the 2019 crop year. With the farm bill development now underway, discussions have become more focused on the longer-term objectives for cotton’s safety net. It has always been the policy goal to get some form of cotton itself (the lint) back into Title I as this clearly offers a more meaningful and efficient level of income support. The policy option has now turned to “seed cotton” – not cottonseed – a combination of both lint and seed. “Seed cotton” refers to unginned cotton (cotton harvested and in the module but not yet ginned and is a combination of lint and seed).
The opportunity to do this presents itself by hopefully being able to temporarily address cotton’s issues within another piece of legislation without opening up the farm bill quite yet – again, trying to provide support as a bridge to a new farm bill beginning in 2019. On December 21, the House passed a Supplemental Disaster funding bill which included an agriculture component to assist producers hit by last year’s hurricanes and wildfires. The bill also included language to address the safety net for both cotton and dairy.
The proposed cotton policy would:
- Establish “seed cotton” as a covered commodity under Title I of the 2014 farm bill and eligible for ARC/PLC.
- The program would be effective with the 2018 crop.
- The proposed Reference Price is 36.7 cents per lb. This is a weighted average price for both lint and seed.
- Generic Base on a farm would no longer exist. Instead, the landowner would have several options to convert Generic Base to seed cotton base and/or bases of seed cotton and other covered commodities.
- Landowners would also have the option to retain the farm’s current cotton CCP yield or update this yield to be used to establish the seed cotton Payment Yield.
- This seed cotton yield would be determined based on a conversion factor for lbs of seed cotton per lb of lint yield.
Consistent with how PLC works for other covered commodities, a seed cotton PLC Payment would be made if the market year average (MYA) price for seed cotton is less than the Reference Price. The proposed seed cotton (SC) reference price is 36.7 cents per lb. The MYA price would also be a weighted average of the lint price and seed price. Any payment would be made on 85% of seed cotton base acres.
The specifics of how these various technical components of a seed cotton program would work have not been publically released. Further, any such provisions are still subject to change. The important general points for producers are:
- This is an effort to address cotton’s safety net and get cotton back in Title I
- To do this, Generic Base (former/old cotton base on a farm that was frozen in the 2014 farm bill) will be converted to seed cotton base. Landowners will have some options on how to do this based on the history of acres planted for covered commodities and cotton.
- The SC Payment Yield can be updated from the farm’s current CCP yield. This too will be based on yield history.
- If approved, this would become effective for the 2018 crop.
The Supplemental Disaster funding bill must still be approved by the Senate. This is a wide-sweeping piece of legislation with a big price tag. Changes are likely. Any differences between the House version and Senate version must then be worked out before the bill can become law. The most recent previous action by the Senate was last summer with the inclusion of support for cotton and dairy in the Agriculture Appropriations package approved by the Senate Appropriations Committee. Those provisions for both cotton and dairy have a different structure than the Supplemental Disaster bill approved last month by the House. For cotton, “cottonseed” is established as a covered commodity eligible for ARC/PLC with Reference Price of $300 per ton.
The Senate is expected to take up the bill early this year. Depending on final passage and when that occurs – and assuming the seed cotton proposal survives – producers and landowners may have a tight window for making decisions. Generic Base has become an important income and management tool on Georgia farms, especially on farms that also grow peanuts. Over half of all peanut acres planted in Georgia are assigned to Generic Base and earn Temporary Base in addition to any Permanent peanut base the farm may have. The decision on alternatives for converting Generic Base to seed cotton base will be crucial and depend on expected payments for seed cotton, peanuts, and other covered commodities.
Regardless of what happens with cotton policy, Generic Base as we now know it will likely cease to exist in the next farm bill. Therefore, it is vital that Generic Base (which is former/previous cotton base) now or in the new farm bill be converted into something of value for the cotton grower.
If approved for 2018, it is hoped that the seed cotton program will be continued into the new farm bill effective in 2019. In addition to the seed cotton program, the cotton industry is also hopeful that the CGCS Program for the 2015 crop will be extended by USDA to cover the 2016 crop. If approved, it is expected that payment will be roughly half of the 2015 amount.
Appreciation is expressed to the National Cotton Council and Southern Cotton Growers for helpful review and comment. Appreciation is also expressed to the Georgia Cotton Commission for funding support.